| | 
EUGLOREH project THE STATUS OF HEALTH IN THE EUROPEAN UNION: TOWARDS A HEALTHIER EUROPE FULL REPORT PART IV - PROTECTING AND PROMOTING PUBLIC HEALTH AND TREATING DISEASES: HEALTH SYSTEMS, SERVICES AND POLICIES 13. THE WAY FORWARD 13.2. Assessing priorities through estimation of the burden of disease 13.2.3. Burden of diseases attributable to specific health determinants. | «» |
13.2.3. Burden of
diseases attributable to specific health determinants.
Attributable
fractions of total disease burden for the developed world (reference year 2000)
were estimated as follows: 13.2% of total disease burden due to tobacco use,
10.9% attributable to hypertension, 7.4% and 7.4% to high cholesterol and
obesity. Worldwide, these fractions were estimated to be 4.1%, 4.4%, 2.8%,
2.3%, respectively. Worldwide, childhood malnutrition attributed the highest
disease burden, i.e. 9.5%. Estimations of environmental disease burden for the
developed world range from 2-6%.
Table 13.4. Burden of disease in
2000 due to selected health determinants for Western Europe, Europe and
worldwide
The first three
determinants in Table 13.6 are typically associated to poverty in developing
countries. Worldwide malnutrition, poor sanitation and indoor air pollution
still produce a substantial burden of disease. Tobacco and alcohol use,
physical inactivity and unhealthy diets are considered to be typical life-style
choices, although one has to consider the important interaction with the social
and physical environment. For instance, people do not choose to be born into
families of lower socioeconomic status. Hypertension, unfavourable blood lipid
composition and obesity are ‘endogenous’ characteristics that develop as a
result of life-style, depending on a person’s genetic make-up. Finally, urban
air pollution and occupational risks are typically the result of exposure to
hazards that are produced collectively within societies.
Globally, an
estimated 24% of the disease burden (healthy life years lost) and an estimated
23% of all premature mortality were due to environmental factors. Potentially sensitive
groups at higher risk for damage or disease from environmental pollutants are
children, people with existing health problems such as diabetes, respiratory
disease, or heart disease and people with compromised immune
systems, including those who have HIV/AIDS or are
undergoing cancer chemotherapy. Poor or other disadvantaged populations who may
live in more polluted environments are exposed to higher concentrations of
pollutants. Children
living in particularly adverse conditions, such as poor and abandoned children,
street children and those who are exploited are at a higher risk of injuries
due to environmental factors. Moreover, certain populations who live in
increasingly agricultural regions, for example, agricultural workers and their
families are especially vulnerable to poisoning from pesticides. A fetus can be
exposed in uterus when their mothers use pesticides, work in sprayed fields, or
work near spraying operations. According to a study made on children aged 0-4
years living in the WHO-Europe region (51 countries), 2-6 % of deaths from all
causes were due to outdoor air pollution. Acute lower respiratory tract
infections due to indoor air pollution accounted for 5% of all deaths and 3 %
of DALYs (disability adjusted life years). Mild mental retardation resulting
from lead exposure accounted for 4 % of DALYs.
In the Netherlands, lost DALYs have been calculated for 49 selected conditions. Table 13.7
presents a comparison of the health loss (in DALYs) due to unhealthy diet and
unsafe food and that due to other lifestyle factors in perspective. A
comparison is also carried out with the health loss due to a number of
significant diseases. The comparison shows that the overall health loss due to
an unhealthy diet is similar to that caused by smoking. The theoretical health
gains which could be achieved merely by adopting a proper dietary composition
(based on all five factors studied) is in second place and is of the same order
as that of reducing obesity (shown here as “energy balance”), or of increasing physical
activity. Moreover, it is shown that a proper dietary composition
could provide health gains equivalent to the overall health loss due to the most
common diseases in the Netherlands, including coronary heart diseases and
depression. Table 13.7 also shows that the demonstrable health loss due to
microbiological contamination of food is comparable to that due to a number of
significant infectious diseases such as AIDS. In the case of chemical
contamination, the health loss is lower than that of a number of major
environmental factors. However, the health loss due to allergens and acrylamide
is greater than that caused by various substances found in the environment. In
the context of health protection, allergens must be considered separately,
since most are normal constituents of certain foods that elicit greatly
differing effects in different people.
|
Table 13.5.
Annual health loss (in DALYs) due to dietary
factors and energy balance, against other lifestyle factors, environmental
factors and disease categories in the Netherlands.
Source: Van Kreil et al (2006)
|
|
DALYs
lost
|
DIET
|
|
OTHER
|
|
DISEASE
|
|
|
Dietary
Factors
|
Microbiological
contamination
|
Chemical
contamination
|
Other
lifestyle factors
|
Environmental
factors
|
Selection
from Public Health Status Forecasts 2002
|
|
>300,000
|
Unhealthy
diet total (1)
|
|
|
Three
life-style factors combined (2) ,
Smoking
|
|
Cardiovascular
diseases, all cancers
|
|
100,000-300,000
|
5
dietary factors together, energy-balance (3)
|
|
|
Lack
of physical activity
|
|
Coronary
heart diseases,
Depression,
lung cancer, diabetes, alcohol-dependency
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
30,000-100,000
|
Excess
of trans fatty acids, too little fruit, vegetables and fish
|
|
|
Alcohol
consumption (4)
|
|
Road
traffic accidents, breast cancer
|
|
10,000-30,000
|
Excess
of saturated fatty acids
|
|
|
|
Particulate
matter in atmosphere
|
Schizophrenia,
prostate cancer, influenza
|
|
3,000
– 10,000
|
|
Gastroenteritis
caused by micro-organisms in food
|
|
|
Passive
Smoking
|
Upper
respiratory tract infections, HIV/AIDS (5), stomach and
intestinal ulcers
|
|
1,000-3,000
|
|
|
|
|
Radon
(interior)
|
Bacterial
meningitis, bacterial STDs (5), tuberculosis
|
|
300-1,000
|
|
Campylobacter
in food
|
Allergens
acrylamide
|
|
|
|
|
<300
|
|
STEC
0175 (5)
|
PAHs
(5) other substances
|
|
Various
substances
|
|
|
1.
Here, ‘unhealthy diet total’ relates to the
overall health loss due to the dietary composition (the five modeled dietary
factors together, in relation to cardiovascular diseases and the relevant
types of cancer) plus the proportion of the health loss attributable to
overweight (due to a positive energy balance)
2.
This relates to the combined effects of
smoking, lack of physical activity or excessive alcohol
consumptions on cardiovascular diseases, diabetes mellitus and the relevant
types of cancer.
3.
Energy balance is the dietary factor which
accounts for the development of overweight. The health loss due to overweight
has been modeled using BMI as indicator. Overweight can also be caused by
lack of physical activity, which falls under ‘ other
lifestyle factors’ in this table
4.
It is assumed here that moderate alcohol
consumption (one to three units per day for men and up to two for women)
prevents cardiovascular diseases, as compared to total abstinence. The health
loss due to alcohol dependency is shown in the seventh (right-hand) column.
5.
HIV/AIDS: Human
Immunodeficiency Virus / Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome; STD: Sexually
Transmitted Disease: STEC: Shiga-toxin-producing Escherichia coli; PAHs:
Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons.
|
|
|
| |