EUGLOREH project
THE STATUS OF HEALTH IN THE EUROPEAN UNION:
TOWARDS A HEALTHIER EUROPE

FULL REPORT

PART I - THE CONTEXT FOR HEALTH

2.   THE CHANGING CONTEXT FOR HEALTH IN THE EUROPEAN UNION

2.8. Energy production

«»

Links:  Standard Highlighted

Link to concordances are always highlighted on mouse hover

2.8. Energy production

 

Due to both population growth and economic growth, energy consumption and resulting greenhouse gas emissions have been increasing in the pan European region, despite energy efficiency improvements and an increased use of renewable energy in certain areas. This trend is expected to continue if no additional policies and measures are implemented. Total energy consumption throughout the pan-European region is growing and remains dominated by fossil fuels. Despite large reductions in some air emissions in parts of Europe, the energy supply sector remains a major contributor to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. Increasing investments in renewable energy production installations in all regions remains a key tool to meeting environmental challenges and to improving security of supply.

Increased use of fuel for domestic use may increase the public health effects. Various forms of electric power generation are associated with public and occupational health impacts along the production life cycle - from fuel extract to waste disposal - or recycling.

In general, renewable energies seem to be preferable especially if no combustion is involved in the different production stages. However, a holistic view is necessary in order to analyze the public health impacts of energy production as a basis for avoiding surprises and reducing risks in the future. The WHO has summarized the health impacts of different forms of electrical power generation below as shown in Table 2.4.

 

 

Table 2.4. Health impacts of different forms of electrical power generation.

 

 

Energy-generating

Resource

 

Direct health impacts

 

 

 

 

 

 

Indirect health impacts (contribution to climate chance)

 

Potential for accidental injuries and/or fatalities

 

Biomass

 

Mainly from acute and chronic effects of outdoor air pollution, but magnitude of health impact depends on combustion process and technology

 

Little net contribution to greenhouse gases over the medium term provided renewable sources used

Usually small and containable risks

 

Coal

 

As for biomass; additional burdens from occupational exposures

 

Forms greenhouse gases, but separate contribution to climate change and resultant health impacts difficult to quantify; impacts delayed

Appreciable occupational risks associated with extraction

 

Geothermal

No significant harmful emissions

Negligible

Minimal

Hydroelectric

 

No significant harmful emissions, but can lead to risks through altered ecology

 

Significant during construction phase; negligible during operation

 

Generally small, except to workers during construction

 

Lignite

 

As for coal; pollutant emissions and hence probably greater health impacts

As for coal

 

As for coal

 

Marine

Negligible

Small/negligible

Small (mainly occupational)

Natural gas

 

Cleaner burning than other fossil fuels, but health effects primarily from air pollution

 

Forms greenhouse gases but generally lower than for other fossil fuels

Some risks mainly during extraction

 

Oil

 

As for biomass; additional burdens from occupational exposures

 

Forms greenhouse gases, but separate contribution to climate

Appreciable occupational risks associated with

 

 

 

 

 

change and resultant health impacts difficult to quantify and delayed

extraction

 

Peat

 

Similar to lignite

 

Comparatively high greenhouse emissions versus coal

Usually small and containable risks

 

Photovoltaic

 

Small

 

Negligible

 

Negligible

 

Nuclear

 

Small risks from release of radioactive material, but containable by effective control systems. Debate about long terni effects from exposure during mining.

 

Minimal (some during reprocessing).

 

Risk from uncontrolled releases of radiation usually small, but finite potential for catastrophic accident or terrorist threat

Waste incineration

 

Mainly from acute and chronic effects of outdoor air pollution, but magnitude of health impaci depends on combustion process and technology

Contributes to greenhouse gases

 

Usually small

 

Wind power

 

No significant harmful emissions

 

Negligible

 

Negligible

 

Source: WHO (2004)

 

Many health outcomes depend on the technology used, occupational health and safety practices, measures of control of pollutant emissions, workers protection legislation and practices and enforcement mechanisms. Many of these activities are under the responsibility of the enterprise. The exposure of the local population is very much dependent on the location of human settlements in relation to pollution dispersal and population vulnerability. Such factors are likely to significantly influence the associated health effects. We have to make sure that the highest measures of protection are adopted by the enterprises and energy companies, in order to control air, soil or water pollutantsimpact on the environment and therewith on human health. Renewable sources, such as photovoltaic and wind energy, are associated with fewer health effects in general. There has been a shift in the types of fuels used, away from coal and towards relatively cleaner ones, such as gas, in several central and Eastern European countries, both in district heating systems and in individual houses. The increased use of renewable energy, especially wind, solar and photovoltaic energy, will have positive health benefits. The production of electricity from nuclear sources has increased. Further major increases in nuclear power are not expected, however, until after 2020, when some increase may be necessary to meet the targets for reducing greenhouse gases. As noted above, addressing public concerns about the human health consequences of nuclear power accidents and nuclear waste disposal is a "must" for policy makers. The market price of energy is also very important for health; in fact, significant increases in prices of essential forms of energy (e.g. as is currently the case for oil) are likely to have a major impact on prices of manufactured and transported goods (e.g. food).