Part, Question

  1 Suppl, 17|        excommunication, thirdly, of indulgences, ~since these two things
  2 Suppl, 25|             25] Out. Para. 1/2 - OF INDULGENCES (THREE ARTICLES)~We must
  3 Suppl, 25|   satisfaction of sins?~(2) Whether indulgences are as effective as they
  4 Suppl, 25|          Church approves and grants indulgences. ~Therefore indulgences
  5 Suppl, 25|             indulgences. ~Therefore indulgences have some value.~Aquin.:
  6 Suppl, 25|         answer that, All admit that indulgences have some value, for it
  7 Suppl, 25|            Church by ~granting such indulgences would do more harm than
  8 Suppl, 25|            say on the contrary that indulgences hold good both in the ~Church'
  9 Suppl, 25|        which is granted by means of indulgences does ~not destroy the proportion
 10 Suppl, 25|            which is not produced by indulgences. But he who ~grants indulgences
 11 Suppl, 25|     indulgences. But he who ~grants indulgences pays the debt of punishment
 12 Suppl, 25|            granted, it follows that indulgences provide a ~remedy against
 13 Suppl, 25|             is not harmful to grant indulgences ~unless this be done without
 14 Suppl, 25|        Nevertheless those who gain ~indulgences should be advised, not,
 15 Suppl, 25|             Thes. Para. 1/1~Whether indulgences are as effective as they
 16 Suppl, 25|           OBJ 1: It would seem that indulgences are not as effective as
 17 Suppl, 25|           as they claim ~to be. For indulgences have no effect save from
 18 Suppl, 25|       penitent's sorrow. Since then indulgences ~depend on the mere will
 19 Suppl, 25|          above all things. Now, if ~indulgences are as effective as they
 20 Suppl, 25|            setting ~himself to gain indulgences might become immune from
 21 Suppl, 25|          and devote himself to gain indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[25] A[
 22 Suppl, 25|            building. If, therefore, indulgences ~produce the effect which
 23 Suppl, 25|       beyond the just estimate. Now indulgences are often ~published which
 24 Suppl, 25|          the Church, in ~publishing indulgences, does not lie; and so they
 25 Suppl, 25|              mortally. If therefore indulgences are not as effective as
 26 Suppl, 25|             to ~be, all who publish indulgences would commit a mortal sin:
 27 Suppl, 25|             For some maintain ~that indulgences have not the efficacy claimed
 28 Suppl, 25|           the Church publishes her ~indulgences in such a way as, by a kind
 29 Suppl, 25|         others have maintained that indulgences avail as much as is ~claimed
 30 Suppl, 25|        First, because in that case ~indulgences would no longer be a remission,
 31 Suppl, 25|           untruth, since, at times, indulgences are granted far in excess
 32 Suppl, 25|           of punishment effected by indulgences is no other than the ~abundance
 33 Suppl, 25|         Hence, according to others, indulgences have precisely the efficacy ~
 34 Suppl, 25|           remission granted through indulgences is ~the effect of this key,
 35 Suppl, 25|             not priests, can ~grant indulgences. Consequently the decision
 36 Suppl, 25|            he sins by granting such indulgences, although the ~indulgence
 37 Suppl, 25|             1~Reply OBJ 2: Although indulgences avail much for the remission
 38 Suppl, 25|           in this way, even without indulgences, a person shares in all
 39 Suppl, 25|             some individual through indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[25] A[
 40 Suppl, 25|       necessary than temporal. ~But indulgences do not appear to be granted
 41 Suppl, 25|             the Church in granting ~indulgences for pilgrimages and almsgiving.~
 42 Suppl, 25|            2 Para. 1/1~Reply OBJ 2: Indulgences can be, and sometimes are,
 43 Suppl, 26|              OF THOSE WHO CAN GRANT INDULGENCES (FOUR ARTICLES)~We must
 44 Suppl, 26|        consider those who can grant indulgences: under which head ~there
 45 Suppl, 26|             parish priest can grant indulgences? ~(2) Whether a deacon or
 46 Suppl, 26|            not a priest, can grant ~indulgences?~(3) Whether a bishop can
 47 Suppl, 26|             parish priest can grant indulgences?~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 48 Suppl, 26|             parish priest can grant indulgences. For ~an indulgence derives
 49 Suppl, 26|            congregation, can ~grant indulgences, and, in like manner, so
 50 Suppl, 26|             seems that he can grant indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 51 Suppl, 26| excommunicate is less than to grant indulgences. But ~a parish priest cannot
 52 Suppl, 26|            Para. 1/2~I answer that, Indulgences are effective, in as much
 53 Suppl, 26|            of the Church can grant ~indulgences. Since, however, the Church
 54 Suppl, 26|         like prelates cannot grant ~indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 55 Suppl, 26|             priest alone can grant ~indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 56 Suppl, 26|           punishment is granted by ~indulgences than by the tribunal of
 57 Suppl, 26|              Therefore he can grant indulgences, ~since they derive their
 58 Suppl, 26|         that, The power of granting indulgences follows jurisdiction, ~as
 59 Suppl, 26|          are not priests can ~grant indulgences, although they cannot absolve
 60 Suppl, 26|             because the granting of indulgences ~belongs to the key of jurisdiction
 61 Suppl, 26|          Whether a bishop can grant indulgences?~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 62 Suppl, 26|          even a bishop cannot grant indulgences. ~Because the treasury of
 63 Suppl, 26|           the Pope alone ~can grant indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 64 Suppl, 26|           with ~which bishops grant indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 65 Suppl, 26|            of the power of granting indulgences ~resides in the Pope, because
 66 Suppl, 26|             Thes. Para. 1/1~Whether indulgences can be granted by one who
 67 Suppl, 26|           OBJ 1: It would seem that indulgences cannot be granted by one
 68 Suppl, 26|      nothing to others by ~granting indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 69 Suppl, 26|          Para. 1/1~On the contrary, Indulgences are granted in virtue of
 70 Suppl, 26|            in mortal sin can grant ~indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[26] A[
 71 Suppl, 26|        answer that, The granting of indulgences belongs to jurisdiction.
 72 Suppl, 26|          jurisdiction. Consequently indulgences ~are equally valid, whether
 73 Suppl, 27|           Para. 1/1 - OF THOSE WHOM INDULGENCES AVAIL (FOUR ARTICLES)~We
 74 Suppl, 27|             now consider those whom indulgences avail: under which head ~
 75 Suppl, 27|             of inquiry:~(1) Whether indulgences avail those who are in mortal
 76 Suppl, 27|            he be in mortal sin. Now indulgences derive their ~efficacy from
 77 Suppl, 27|         receives no inflow, through indulgences, from the merits of ~living
 78 Suppl, 27|         answer that, Some hold that indulgences avail those even who are
 79 Suppl, 27|            of the Church neither by indulgences nor in ~the tribunal of
 80 Suppl, 27|          conditions for gaining all indulgences. If however the merits were ~
 81 Suppl, 27|             Thes. Para. 1/1~Whether indulgences avail religious?~Aquin.:
 82 Suppl, 27|           OBJ 1: It would seem that indulgences do not avail religious.
 83 Suppl, 27|           their ~own abundance. Now indulgences are derived from the abundance
 84 Suppl, 27| unreasonable for ~them to profit by indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[27] A[
 85 Suppl, 27|             in ~the Church. But, if indulgences were to avail religious,
 86 Suppl, 27|           become lax on ~account of indulgences, and would neglect the penances
 87 Suppl, 27|      imposed in ~chapter. Therefore indulgences do not avail religious.~
 88 Suppl, 27|          profit to ~be derived from indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[27] A[
 89 Suppl, 27|            Para. 1/1~I answer that, Indulgences avail both seculars and
 90 Suppl, 27|          conditions for gaining the indulgences: ~for religious can be helped
 91 Suppl, 27|          religious can be helped by indulgences no less than persons living
 92 Suppl, 27|      expiate this debt by means of ~indulgences. For it is not unreasonable
 93 Suppl, 27|              There is no reason why indulgences should be detrimental to ~
 94 Suppl, 27|          their rule than by gaining indulgences; ~although, as to the remission
 95 Suppl, 27|            merit less. Nor again do indulgences remit the punishment enjoined
 96 Suppl, 27|            OBJ 3: Further, to grant indulgences and to excommunicate belong
 97 Suppl, 27|           of punishment by means of indulgences.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[27] A[
 98 Suppl, 71|          the departed?~(10) Whether indulgences granted by the Church profit
 99 Suppl, 71|         Thes. Para. 1/1~Whether the indulgences of the Church profit the
100 Suppl, 71|              It would seem that the indulgences granted by the Church profit ~
101 Suppl, 71|        profited the dead. Therefore indulgences profit the dead.~Aquin.:
102 Suppl, 71|         merit of the Church whereon indulgences are founded.~Aquin.: SMT
103 Suppl, 71|             1/1~OBJ 3: Further, the indulgences of the Church profit those
104 Suppl, 71|       Therefore ~it would seem that indulgences profit the departed.~Aquin.:
105 Suppl, 71|             contrary, In order that indulgences may avail a person, there ~
106 Suppl, 71|           is for such a cause that ~indulgences are chiefly granted. Therefore,
107 Suppl, 71|      granted. Therefore, seemingly, indulgences profit ~not the dead.~Aquin.:
108 Suppl, 71|              OTC Para. 2/2~Further, indulgences are regulated according
109 Suppl, 71|         grants them. If, therefore, indulgences could avail the dead, ~it
110 Suppl, 71|             those things for which ~indulgences are granted, indulgences
111 Suppl, 71|            indulgences are granted, indulgences cannot avail them directly.
112 Suppl, 71|            common ~suffrages whence indulgences derive their value, as stated
113 Suppl, 71|          the common merits, whereon indulgences are based, to the living ~
114 Suppl, 71|         just as he lists, since for indulgences to ~avail there must be