Part, Question
1 1, 21 | Philosopher (Ethic. v, 4) calls ~commutative justice, that directs exchange
2 2, 60 | of another species from commutative justice; but ~about this
3 2, 59 | justice, i.e. distributive and commutative ~justice; (2) the quasi-integral
4 2, 59 | would seem to be an act of commutative justice, we must ~consider (
5 2, 59 | the distinction between commutative and distributive ~justice; (
6 2, 59 | viz. distributive and ~commutative?~(2) Whether in either case
7 2, 59 | suitably assigned, viz. commutative ~and distributive?~Aquin.:
8 2, 59 | assigned, viz. distributive and commutative. That which is hurtful to
9 2, 59 | species of a ~virtue. Now commutative justice consists in rendering
10 2, 59 | This ~order is directed by commutative justice, which is concerned
11 2, 59 | justice, ~distributive and commutative.~Aquin.: SMT SS Q[61] A[
12 2, 59 | OBJ 5: Distributive and commutative justice differ not only
13 2, 59 | way in distributive as in ~commutative justice?~Aquin.: SMT SS
14 2, 59 | observed in the same way as in commutative justice. For each of these
15 2, 59 | in both ~distributive and commutative justice.~Aquin.: SMT SS
16 2, 59 | are considered also in commutative justice, for instance, in
17 2, 59 | proportion," ~whereas in commutative justice it follows "arithmetical
18 2, 59 | wherein ~distributive and commutative justice agree: but in one
19 2, 59 | considered in itself, whereas in commutative justice it is considered
20 2, 59 | Therefore, if distributive and ~commutative justice have different matters,
21 2, 59 | another, and ~this belongs to commutative justice. Therefore the matters
22 2, 59 | matters of ~distributive and commutative justice are not distinct.~
23 2, 59 | justice differs from that ~of commutative justice, for the reason
24 2, 59 | Philosopher (Ethic. v, 2) reckons commutative justice as ~one species,
25 2, 59 | matter of distributive and commutative justice is the same, ~since
26 2, 59 | directs distributions, while commutative justice ~directs commutations
27 2, 59 | species of justice, namely commutative justice. And this suffices
28 2, 59 | the community; while in commutative ~justice it regards the
29 2, 59 | according to the requirements of commutative justice, namely ~that the
30 2, 59 | retaliation is in accordance with commutative justice: but there is no ~
31 2, 59 | with the ~conditions of commutative justice, in so far as rewards
32 2, 59 | this is to be referred to commutative, not distributive, ~justice.
33 2, 60 | restitution is an act of commutative justice?~Aquin.: SMT SS
34 2, 60 | restitution is not an act of commutative ~justice. For justice regards
35 2, 60 | restitution is not more an act of commutative than of ~distributive justice.~
36 2, 60 | away. Now it is an act ~of commutative injustice to take away what
37 2, 60 | another, and this belongs to commutative justice. Hence restitution
38 2, 60 | restitution is an ~act of commutative justice, occasioned by one
39 2, 60 | consequently it pertains to commutative justice.~Aquin.: SMT SS
40 2, 60 | above (A[1]) is an act of ~commutative justice, and this demands
41 2, 60 | re-establishes the equality of commutative ~justice, which equality
42 2, 60 | according to ~the form of commutative justice. On the other hand,
43 2, 61 | consider the vices opposed to ~commutative justice.~Aquin.: SMT SS
44 2, 61 | seem to pertain chiefly to commutative justice. Therefore respect
45 2, 61 | way judgment is common to commutative and ~distributive justice:
46 2, 61 | in as much as, even in ~commutative justice, the judge takes
47 2, 62 | 1/2 - VICES OPPOSED TO COMMUTATIVE JUSTICE (QQ[64]-81)~(A)
48 2, 62 | consider the vices opposed to commutative ~justice. We must consider (
49 2, 65 | consider those vices opposed to commutative justice, that ~consist in
50 2, 75 | Para. 1/1~Reply OBJ 3: In commutative justice we consider chiefly
51 2, 78 | seemingly a ~species of commutative justice whereby revenge
52 2, 78 | judge's sentence, belongs to commutative justice: ~whereas the revenge
53 2, 104| proportionate repayment belongs to commutative justice, ~according to the
54 2, 104| Proportionate repayment belongs to commutative justice, ~when it answers
55 2, 106| virtue, but is an act of commutative justice. ~Therefore in the
56 2, 106| a legal debt belongs to commutative ~justice, and as repayment
57 2, 106| public justice, is an ~act of commutative justice; while so far as
58 2, 115| matter of ~distributive and commutative justice. Therefore they
59 3, 85 | viz. "distributive" and "commutative." But penance does not seem
60 3, 85 | both are comprised under commutative justice.~Aquin.: SMT TP
61 3, 85 | moderates, are objects of commutative ~justice. Accordingly it
|