Part, Question

1501 Suppl, 71|             not unreasonable that the punishment of those who are ~in purgatory
1502 Suppl, 71|              unpunished, because the ~punishment of one undertaken in lieu
1503 Suppl, 71|          purifying of the soul by the punishment of purgatory is ~nothing
1504 Suppl, 71|         person can be expiated by the punishment which another undergoes
1505 Suppl, 71|              to be released ~from his punishment, he will in this respect
1506 Suppl, 71|             another's fault - and the punishment of purgatory is ~temporal -
1507 Suppl, 71|             are very bad, since their punishment is very ~light. Therefore
1508 Suppl, 71|               the essential reward or punishment, the suffrages of the living ~
1509 Suppl, 71|         assisted by them chiefly. For punishment should ~compensate for punishment.
1510 Suppl, 71|     punishment should ~compensate for punishment. Now fasting is more penal
1511 Suppl, 71|        another, rather ~than even the punishment undergone by way of satisfaction;
1512 Suppl, 71|           satisfaction; although the ~punishment expiates more the guilt
1513 Suppl, 71|        deceased ~person entirely from punishment: which is apparently absurd.~
1514 Suppl, 71|          respect of the diminution of punishment; for after death ~there
1515 Suppl, 71|         directed to the ~remission of punishment. Consequently, as regards
1516 Suppl, 71|             regards the remission of ~punishment, suffrages avail chiefly
1517 Suppl, 71|               the expiation of their ~punishment. But this is as nothing
1518 Suppl, 71|             finally released from all punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[71] A[
1519 Suppl, 71|            not follow that the whole ~punishment of those who are in purgatory
1520 Suppl, 72|             be wholly delivered from ~punishment. Since then the saints in
1521 Suppl, 72|           would deliver entirely from punishment those who are in ~purgatory.
1522 Suppl, 72|                free the dead from the punishment which the latter have not
1523 Suppl, 72|             they may ~bear an eternal punishment. Therefore this fire will
1524 Suppl, 72|             be cast into hell for the punishment of ~the damned.~Aquin.:
1525 Suppl, 72|               down into ~hell for the punishment of the wicked, and whatever
1526 Suppl, 72|            Para. 1/1~Reply OBJ 3: The punishment of the wicked, even as the
1527 Suppl, 72|          Further, bodily death is the punishment inflicted on man for his ~
1528 Suppl, 72|              character of sin, so the punishment which is awarded to ~them
1529 Suppl, 72|             Christ's death: hence its punishment lasts not for ever. ~But
1530 Suppl, 72|             Para. 1/1~OBJ 4: Further, punishment is not remitted unless the
1531 Suppl, 72|               Now bodily death is the punishment of original sin. Therefore,
1532 Suppl, 72|               rise ~again may receive punishment or reward according to their
1533 Suppl, 72|             their merits. Now ~either punishment or reward is due to all,
1534 Suppl, 72|      obligation of death which is the punishment of original ~sin. Hence,
1535 Suppl, 72|            again from death: ~for the punishment of original sin is to die,
1536 Suppl, 75|        original sin. But death is the punishment of ~original sin. Therefore
1537 Suppl, 75|              sin, although death is a punishment of ~original sin; because
1538 Suppl, 75|            can of His mercy remit the punishment which one ~has incurred
1539 Suppl, 75|             adulterous woman without ~punishment (Jn. 8): and in like manner
1540 Suppl, 75|               by Divine justice as a ~punishment on man, so was the decay
1541 Suppl, 77|            for evil deeds, since the ~punishment of the member would redound
1542 Suppl, 77|           member would redound to the punishment of man. ~Therefore the members
1543 Suppl, 78|      resurrection unto glory or ~unto punishment. But there will not be the
1544 Suppl, 78|            same quantity of glory or ~punishment in all those who rise again.
1545 Suppl, 83|              which was appointed as a punishment for sin ~should not cease
1546 Suppl, 83|     deformities, this will be for his punishment. Now the mode of ~punishment
1547 Suppl, 83|          punishment. Now the mode of ~punishment is according to the measure
1548 Suppl, 83|           though deserving of greater punishment, the mode of the ~punishment
1549 Suppl, 83|          punishment, the mode of the ~punishment would not correspond to
1550 Suppl, 83|               Since in every tribunal punishment is inflicted according ~
1551 Suppl, 83|             shall suffer more severe ~punishment for eternity.~Aquin.: SMT
1552 Suppl, 83|          punished with an everlasting punishment both ~in soul and body (
1553 Suppl, 83|            shall go into everlasting ~punishment." But this would not be
1554 Suppl, 83|        contribute to the ~increase of punishment. For as the Philosopher
1555 Suppl, 83|              consigned to everlasting punishment. Now the Divine justice
1556 Suppl, 84|      repentance remain in the debt of punishment due to them, ~while those
1557 Suppl, 84|               publication will be the punishment of man's neglect in ~omitting
1558 Suppl, 85|            Heb. 11:13,39,40), and the punishment of ~one conduces to the
1559 Suppl, 85|     punishments for one sin, and the ~punishment which before the judgment
1560 Suppl, 85|               torment from the ~added punishment of the body and from the
1561 Suppl, 86|        approval), or the repayment of punishment ~and reward (which is like
1562 Suppl, 86|               in any way diminish the punishment ~of the demons, since even
1563 Suppl, 86|              receive their ~principal punishment immediately from God, namely
1564 Suppl, 86|                1/1~Reply OBJ 1: Since punishment is the effect of justice,
1565 Suppl, 86|             of mercy, it follows that punishment is more especially ~ascribed
1566 Suppl, 86|           wicked will be sentenced to punishment according to the ~degree
1567 Suppl, 86|             regards the sentencing to punishment for ~sin concerns all the
1568 Suppl, 87|        humanity will conduce to their punishment, as stated ~above (A[2],
1569 Suppl, 88|             before sin, but ~not as a punishment to man. Nor does it follow
1570 Suppl, 89|           privation and thus ~it is a punishment: for in this way ignorance
1571 Suppl, 91|            the blessed rejoice in the punishment of the wicked?~Aquin.: SMT
1572 Suppl, 91|         blessed do not rejoice in the punishment ~of the wicked. For rejoicing
1573 Suppl, 91|         blessed nowise rejoice in the punishment of the ~damned.~Aquin.:
1574 Suppl, 91|          blessed will ~rejoice in the punishment of the wicked.~Aquin.: SMT
1575 Suppl, 91|              will ~not rejoice in the punishment of the wicked. Secondly,
1576 Suppl, 91|           saints will ~rejoice in the punishment of the wicked, by considering
1577 Suppl, 91|             of the blessed: while the punishment of the ~damned will cause
1578 Suppl, 92|            right to receive; or as a ~punishment on the bridegroom, that
1579 Suppl, 93|             of freedom, since it is a punishment ~inflicted by another person
1580 Suppl, 93|             Para. 1/1~OBJ 2: Further, punishment in soul and body corresponds
1581 Suppl, 94|               Out. Para. 1/2 - OF THE PUNISHMENT OF THE DAMNED (SEVEN ARTICLES)~
1582 Suppl, 94|           after the judgment: (1) The punishment of the damned, and the fire
1583 Suppl, 94|               tormented with the sole punishment of ~fire?~(2) Whether the
1584 Suppl, 94|             are tormented by the sole punishment of fire?~Aquin.: SMT XP
1585 Suppl, 94|            are tormented by the sole ~punishment of fire; because Mt. 25:
1586 Suppl, 94|               2: Further, even as the punishment of purgatory is due to venial ~
1587 Suppl, 94|             to venial ~sin, so is the punishment of hell due to mortal sin.
1588 Suppl, 94|             mortal sin. Now no other ~punishment but that of fire is stated
1589 Suppl, 94|               in hell will there be a punishment other ~than of fire.~Aquin.:
1590 Suppl, 94|            OBJ 3: Further, variety of punishment affords a respite, as when
1591 Suppl, 94|              being ~cast down for the punishment of the damned: so that just
1592 Suppl, 94|            Para. 1/1~Reply OBJ 2: The punishment of purgatory is not intended
1593 Suppl, 94|              cleansing power. But the punishment of ~the damned is not directed
1594 Suppl, 94|            fire and worm, will be the punishment of the body." Therefore,
1595 Suppl, 94|              the restless worm in the punishment of the damned are explained ~
1596 Suppl, 94|              Further, the pain of the punishment corresponds to the pleasure ~
1597 Suppl, 94|              the damned see their own punishment, for this increases ~their
1598 Suppl, 94|             for this increases ~their punishment. But nothing is seen without
1599 Suppl, 94|          Other points relating to the punishment of the damned have been
1600 Suppl, 94|        spiritual and not a corporeal ~punishment. Therefore they will be
1601 Suppl, 94|               as seem to imply bodily punishment - for ~instance, that they
1602 Suppl, 94|                Since, however, in the punishment of the damned there will
1603 Suppl, 94|              hold the above manner of punishment. For this ~reason Avicenna
1604 Suppl, 94|            seems to hold this kind of punishment (Gen. ~ad lit. xii, 32),
1605 Suppl, 94|              cannot fittingly apply a punishment to a body unless that ~punishment
1606 Suppl, 94|     punishment to a body unless that ~punishment itself be bodily. Wherefore
1607 Suppl, 94|               acts on them for their ~punishment by a kind of spiritual action,
1608 Suppl, 94|            Divine justice ~inflicting punishment. Now an instrument acts
1609 Suppl, 94|          Pythagoras held the place of punishment to be in a fiery sphere ~
1610 Suppl, 94|                as though the place of punishment ~were outside the whole
1611 Suppl, 94|             sin has its corresponding punishment, since "inordinate ~love
1612 Suppl, 94|           inordinate ~love is its own punishment," as Augustine states (Confess.
1613 Suppl, 95|       connected with it, for instance punishment or something of that ~kind.
1614 Suppl, 95|             they will suffer from the punishment ~inflicted on them for sin.~
1615 Suppl, 95|             will wickedness, but shun punishment: and thus ~indirectly they
1616 Suppl, 95|           something else, namely the ~punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[98] A[
1617 Suppl, 95|         desire the increase of their ~punishment. Now if more were damned,
1618 Suppl, 95|               more were damned, their punishment would be greater, ~even
1619 Suppl, 95|             many companions in their ~punishment."~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[98] A[
1620 Suppl, 95|               than others, and their ~punishment would be greater if all
1621 Suppl, 95|             an increase of each one's punishment, so much the more will their
1622 Suppl, 95|         damned, perceiving God in His punishment, which is the effect of
1623 Suppl, 95|            Him, even as they hate the punishment inflicted on them ~[*Cf.
1624 Suppl, 95|             wherefore God inflicted a punishment ~on the serpent, who induced
1625 Suppl, 95|         drunken man deserves a double punishment" ~if he commit a crime through
1626 Suppl, 95|           Para. 1/2 ~On the contrary, Punishment is contradistinguished from
1627 Suppl, 95|              obstinacy which is their punishment. Therefore the perverse
1628 Suppl, 95|               be not a demerit but a ~punishment only. For works of virtue
1629 Suppl, 95|            reward or to the principal punishment, since in this respect both
1630 Suppl, 95|      accidental ~reward, or secondary punishment, which are subject to increase
1631 Suppl, 95|               damnation, whereby the ~punishment of the demons is augmented [*
1632 Suppl, 95|               regards their secondary punishment [*Cf. FP, Q[62], A[9], ad
1633 Suppl, 95|               will this lessen their ~punishment, but will increase it; because
1634 Suppl, 96|             Divine justice an eternal punishment is inflicted on ~sinners?~(
1635 Suppl, 96|            Whether by God's mercy all punishment both of men and of demons ~
1636 Suppl, 96|               3) Whether at least the punishment of men comes to an end?~(
1637 Suppl, 96|               4) Whether at least the punishment of Christians has an end?~(
1638 Suppl, 96|        Whether there is an end to the punishment of those who have ~performed
1639 Suppl, 96|             Divine justice an eternal punishment is inflicted on sinners? ~[*
1640 Suppl, 96|            would seem that an eternal punishment is not inflicted on ~sinners
1641 Suppl, 96|               Divine justice. For the punishment should not exceed the ~fault: "
1642 Suppl, 96|               temporal. Therefore the punishment ~should not be eternal.~
1643 Suppl, 96|              should receive a greater punishment than the other. But no ~
1644 Suppl, 96|               than the other. But no ~punishment is greater than eternal
1645 Suppl, 96|               is greater than eternal punishment, since it is infinite. ~
1646 Suppl, 96|          infinite. ~Therefore eternal punishment is not due to every sin;
1647 Suppl, 96|            thereby. Therefore eternal punishment is not ~inflicted for sins
1648 Suppl, 96|                Now God does not wish ~punishment for its own sake, for He
1649 Suppl, 96|         result from the perpetuity of punishment, it would seem ~that He
1650 Suppl, 96|           ought not to inflict such a punishment for sin.~Aquin.: SMT XP
1651 Suppl, 96|               Coelo et Mundo ~i). But punishment is one of those things that
1652 Suppl, 96|             brought to ~naught, their punishment cannot be everlasting. Therefore
1653 Suppl, 96|             shall go into everlasting punishment."~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[99] A[
1654 Suppl, 96|             reward is to merit, so is punishment to guilt. Now, ~according
1655 Suppl, 96|         Divine justice an everlasting punishment is due to temporal guilt.~
1656 Suppl, 96|            Philosopher (Ethic. v, 5), punishment is meted ~according to the
1657 Suppl, 96|          authority receives a greater punishment than one who ~strikes anyone
1658 Suppl, 96|            mortally deserves infinite punishment; and consequently it ~seems
1659 Suppl, 96|              1/2~I answer that, Since punishment is measured in two ways,
1660 Suppl, 96|              of ~time, the measure of punishment corresponds to the measure
1661 Suppl, 96|               7). The duration of the punishment does not, however, ~correspond
1662 Suppl, 96|               1]. But the duration of punishment regards the ~disposition
1663 Suppl, 96|              member of the State, his punishment is ~prolonged or curtailed,
1664 Suppl, 96|              condemned to everlasting punishment, because as Augustine says (
1665 Suppl, 96|             imperishable ~city by the punishment of the second death." That
1666 Suppl, 96|               second death." That the punishment ~inflicted by the earthly
1667 Suppl, 96|               man lived for ever, the punishment of exile ~or slavery, which
1668 Suppl, 96|               who sin venially, their punishment will be so much the shorter
1669 Suppl, 96|              condemned to everlasting punishment for a temporal sin. One
1670 Suppl, 96|              not deserving of eternal punishment, it must be ~replied according
1671 Suppl, 96|           reason may be given why the punishment of mortal sin ~is eternal:
1672 Suppl, 96|            infinite. Wherefore ~since punishment cannot be infinite in intensity,
1673 Suppl, 96|               after death; nor should punishment cease so long as ~guilt
1674 Suppl, 96|              1 Para. 1/1~Reply OBJ 1: Punishment has not to be equal to fault
1675 Suppl, 96|            degree of intensity in the punishment corresponds to ~the degree
1676 Suppl, 96|                gravity will receive a punishment unequal in intensity but
1677 Suppl, 96|          Reply OBJ 4: The everlasting punishment of the wicked will not be ~
1678 Suppl, 96|            for ever unappeased by the punishment of ~the wicked." Secondly,
1679 Suppl, 96|             all condemned to ~eternal punishment, and are punished for their
1680 Suppl, 96|             Reply OBJ 5: Although the punishment relates to the soul accidentally, ~
1681 Suppl, 96|             in the soul for ever, its punishment also will be everlasting.~
1682 Suppl, 96|              6 Para. 1/1~Reply OBJ 6: Punishment corresponds to fault, properly
1683 Suppl, 96|               latter were the case, a punishment of ~infinite intensity would
1684 Suppl, 96|                of being cannot be the punishment due to any sin.~Aquin.:
1685 Suppl, 96|            Whether by God's mercy all punishment of the damned, both men
1686 Suppl, 96|               that by God's mercy all punishment of the damned, ~both men
1687 Suppl, 96|       creatures. Therefore also their punishment will come to an end.~Aquin.:
1688 Suppl, 96|               be delivered from their punishment." But this error ~has been
1689 Suppl, 96|               entirely delivered from punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[99] A[
1690 Suppl, 96|             is ~not distinct from His punishment, man will not be punished
1691 Suppl, 96|         deliver the damned from their punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[99] A[
1692 Suppl, 96|              God's foretelling of the punishment of the damned ~belongs to
1693 Suppl, 96|           will the threat of eternal ~punishment be commuted by God's mercy
1694 Suppl, 96|              mercy for a more lenient punishment, when ~this will be able
1695 Suppl, 96|                But God's anger is His punishment. Therefore, etc.~Aquin.:
1696 Suppl, 96|             shall go into everlasting punishment: but the just, ~into life
1697 Suppl, 96|              is inadmissible that the punishment ~of the damned will ever
1698 Suppl, 96|            after ~death: and thus the punishment of the damned will have
1699 Suppl, 96|              at ~length set free from punishment. But this statement is altogether ~
1700 Suppl, 96|              Para. 1/1~Reply OBJ 3: A punishment threatened prophetically
1701 Suppl, 96|               changed, the threatened punishment will ever be fulfilled in
1702 Suppl, 96|               His anger," because the punishment will not be done away entirely;
1703 Suppl, 96|             effect by diminishing the punishment while it ~continues.~Aquin.:
1704 Suppl, 96|           Thes. Para. 1/1~Whether the punishment of Christians is brought
1705 Suppl, 96|          would seem that at least the punishment of Christians is ~brought
1706 Suppl, 96|               a delivery from eternal punishment not for ~all men, but only
1707 Suppl, 96|          would be immune from eternal punishment. But this is contrary to ~
1708 Suppl, 96|               be exempt from eternal ~punishment who have received the sacraments
1709 Suppl, 96|               lesser but of a greater punishment, since ~according to 2 Pt.
1710 Suppl, 96|               are exempt from eternal punishment, who persevere to the end
1711 Suppl, 96|        threatens sinners with eternal punishment. Consequently ~those who
1712 Suppl, 96|               be exempt from ~eternal punishment, unless in the end they
1713 Suppl, 96|       temporal tribulation, or of the punishment of purgatory which will
1714 Suppl, 96|              mercy. Therefore eternal punishment will be awarded only ~to
1715 Suppl, 96|               will suffer everlasting punishment." ~Therefore those who persevere
1716 Suppl, 96|            will be freed from eternal punishment, but only those who ~persevere
1717 Suppl, 96|             to exemption from eternal punishment, as may be gathered ~from
1718 Suppl, 96|           will free them from eternal punishment, not even after any length ~
1719 Suppl, 96|            rebates somewhat their due punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[99] A[
1720 Suppl, 96|          mercy is not because eternal punishment will be inflicted on none
1721 Suppl, 96|            works, but because eternal punishment will be ~remitted to those
1722 Suppl, 96|             works ~of mercy after the punishment of purgatory, which he calls
1723 Appen1, 1|               and are inflicted ~with punishment by fire?~(2) Whether these
1724 Appen1, 1|          punished everlastingly." Now punishment denotes sensible pain. ~
1725 Appen1, 1|              fault deserves a greater punishment. Now ~original sin is greater
1726 Appen1, 1|              sin is ~deserving of the punishment of fire, much more so is
1727 Appen1, 1|             for mercy. Now, sensible ~punishment corresponds to original
1728 Appen1, 1|      punishments. ~Therefore sensible punishment is due to it after this
1729 Appen1, 1|         namely concupiscence. Now the punishment of fire is due to ~actual
1730 Appen1, 1|            they will ~suffer sensible punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1731 Appen1, 1|              xxiii) that the mildest ~punishment of all will be for those
1732 Appen1, 1|              tormented with sensible ~punishment, because the pain of hell
1733 Appen1, 1|              will not suffer sensible punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1734 Appen1, 1|        Further, the grief of sensible punishment corresponds to the pleasure
1735 Appen1, 1|             in Ethic. x, 4. Therefore punishment by fire ~is not due to original
1736 Appen1, 1|         therefore suffer the eternal ~punishment suffered by the damned: "
1737 Appen1, 1|            for that reason ~worthy of punishment, and on the other hand he
1738 Appen1, 1|              who is not deserving of ~punishment is not for that reason worthy
1739 Appen1, 1|              Para. 1/1~I answer that, Punishment should be proportionate
1740 Appen1, 1|           keep. Wherefore no further ~punishment is due to him, besides the
1741 Appen1, 1|         vision is the proper and only punishment of original sin after ~death:
1742 Appen1, 1|        because, if any other sensible punishment were inflicted after ~death
1743 Appen1, 1|              his ~guilt, for sensible punishment is inflicted for that which
1744 Appen1, 1|              a man undergoes sensible punishment in so far as he ~suffers
1745 Appen1, 1|               In the authority quoted punishment denotes, not pain of ~sense,
1746 Appen1, 1|               to signify any ~kind of punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1747 Appen1, 1|              is; wherefore ~a lighter punishment is due to original than
1748 Appen1, 1|         character, not of sin, but of punishment, except in so far ~as it
1749 Appen1, 1|             is deserving of ~temporal punishment, since this is accidental,
1750 Appen1, 1|     sufficient grace to attenuate the punishment. For if ~venial sin were
1751 Appen1, 1|            not correspond ~thereto as punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1752 Appen1, 1|              justice will not suffer ~punishment. On the other hand, the
1753 Appen1, 1|            Hom. xxiii in Matth.), the punishment of God in that ~they will
1754 Appen1, 1|            but increases the pain of ~punishment: for a man does not grieve
1755 Appen1, 1|            for their sin or for their punishment. If ~for their sin, since
1756 Appen1, 1|              would not be the mildest punishment, ~as Augustine says it is [*
1757 Appen1, 1|           hand, they grieve for their punishment, it follows, since their ~
1758 Appen1, 1|              it follows, since their ~punishment is justly inflicted by God,
1759 Appen1, 1|            for that they undergo this punishment which they could nowise ~
1760 Appen1, 1|             recovery: wherefore their punishment would not be the mildest.
1761 Appen1, 1|           within, because the pain of punishment corresponds to the pleasure ~
1762 Appen1, 1|              is void of pleasure, its punishment ~is free of all pain. Consequently
1763 Appen1, 2|             EXPIATE ACTUAL SIN OR ITS PUNISHMENT IN PURGATORY (SIX ARTICLES) ~(
1764 Appen1, 2|          after this life expiate the ~punishment of their actual sins in
1765 Appen1, 2|           this life?~(2) Whether that punishment is voluntary?~(3) Whether
1766 Appen1, 2|      Purgatory frees from the debt of punishment?~(6) Whether one is freed
1767 Appen1, 2|        Whether one is freed from that punishment sooner than another?~Aquin.:
1768 Appen1, 2|               grievous, the lightest ~punishment is due to them, if the measure
1769 Appen1, 2|            Further, since the debt of punishment is an effect of sin, it ~
1770 Appen1, 2|            not fully paid the debt of punishment, this ~debt does not increase
1771 Appen1, 2|           extent of the most grievous punishment. Therefore the pain ~that
1772 Appen1, 2|             Therefore this, being the punishment of the separate soul, is ~
1773 Appen1, 2|            the pain of ~sense, namely punishment by corporeal fire. With
1774 Appen1, 2|               since in that case the ~punishment of the damned would be milder
1775 Appen1, 2|               2: The severity of that punishment is not so much a ~consequence
1776 Appen1, 2|               same crimes to the same punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1777 Appen1, 2|                Para. 1/1~Whether this punishment is voluntary?~Aquin.: SMT
1778 Appen1, 2|               It would seem that this punishment is voluntary. For those
1779 Appen1, 2|                they will suffer ~that punishment voluntarily.~Aquin.: SMT
1780 Appen1, 2|               asks to be freed from a punishment that he ~suffers willingly.
1781 Appen1, 2|            they will not undergo that punishment voluntarily.~Aquin.: SMT
1782 Appen1, 2|              of the will; and thus no punishment is voluntary, because ~the
1783 Appen1, 2|           because ~the very notion of punishment is that it be contrary to
1784 Appen1, 2|            regaining health. Hence a ~punishment may be voluntary in two
1785 Appen1, 2|              will itself undertakes a punishment, as ~instanced in satisfaction,
1786 Appen1, 2|               or when a man accepts a punishment gladly, and ~would not have
1787 Appen1, 2|       although we gain no good by the punishment, we cannot obtain a good ~
1788 Appen1, 2|           will does not undertake the punishment, and would be delivered
1789 Appen1, 2|               and in this respect the punishment is said to be ~voluntary.
1790 Appen1, 2|              In this latter sense the punishment of Purgatory is said to
1791 Appen1, 2|            take them to the ~place of punishment: also that even the demons,
1792 Appen1, 2|           demons, who rejoice in the ~punishment of man, accompany them and
1793 Appen1, 2|              angels sometimes inflict punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1794 Appen1, 2|            this be understood of ~the punishment: because thus all sins,
1795 Appen1, 2|                as regards the debt of punishment. ~Therefore venial sins
1796 Appen1, 2|              venial ~sins as to their punishment, as the Master says in the
1797 Appen1, 2|          remission of ~sin diminishes punishment rather than aggravates it.
1798 Appen1, 2|              Purgatory: ~because this punishment so far as it is voluntary,
1799 Appen1, 2|              Guilt is not remitted by punishment, but venial sin as to its ~
1800 Appen1, 2|             man merited here that his punishment should be ~meritorious to
1801 Appen1, 2|             delivers from the debt of punishment?~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1802 Appen1, 2|             deliver from ~the debt of punishment. For every cleansing is
1803 Appen1, 2|             of some ~uncleanness. But punishment does not imply uncleanness.
1804 Appen1, 2|       Purgatory does not deliver from punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1805 Appen1, 2|            save by its contrary. But ~punishment is not contrary to punishment.
1806 Appen1, 2|         punishment is not contrary to punishment. Therefore one is not cleansed ~
1807 Appen1, 2|            cleansed ~from the debt of punishment by the punishment of Purgatory.~
1808 Appen1, 2|             debt of punishment by the punishment of Purgatory.~Aquin.: SMT
1809 Appen1, 2|         Therefore ~man expiates every punishment by the pains of this world,
1810 Appen1, 2|          death, which is the greatest punishment of all, and not by the fire
1811 Appen1, 2|                 Now the satisfactory ~punishment which one undergoes in this
1812 Appen1, 2|               atones for the debt of ~punishment. Much more therefore is
1813 Appen1, 2|               is this effected by the punishment of ~Purgatory.~Aquin.: SMT
1814 Appen1, 2|         nothing else than the debt of punishment, a person is freed from ~
1815 Appen1, 2|          obligation by undergoing the punishment which he owed. Accordingly ~
1816 Appen1, 2|             he owed. Accordingly ~the punishment of Purgatory cleanses from
1817 Appen1, 2|             cleanses from the debt of punishment.~Aquin.: SMT XP App. 1 Q[
1818 Appen1, 2|               1: Although the debt of punishment does not in itself imply ~
1819 Appen1, 2|               1~Reply OBJ 2: Although punishment is not contrary to punishment,
1820 Appen1, 2|         punishment is not contrary to punishment, it is ~opposed to the debt
1821 Appen1, 2|                opposed to the debt of punishment, because the obligation
1822 Appen1, 2|             because the obligation to punishment ~remains from the fact that
1823 Appen1, 2|             one has not undergone the punishment that was ~due.~Aquin.: SMT
1824 Appen1, 2|           present tribulation and the punishment to ~come, and venial sins
1825 Appen1, 2|         person is delivered from this punishment sooner than another?~Aquin.:
1826 Appen1, 2|              not delivered from this ~punishment sooner than another. For
1827 Appen1, 2|            proportion between severer punishment and graver fault, ~as between
1828 Appen1, 2|            fault, ~as between lighter punishment and less grievous fault.
1829 Appen1, 2|               is ~delivered from this punishment as soon as another.~Aquin.:
1830 Appen1, 2|              Reply OBJ 1: Severity of punishment corresponds properly speaking
1831 Appen1, 2|         Mortal sin which deserves the punishment of hell, and ~charity which
1832 Appen2, 1|             is mortal sin to ~eternal punishment. Now those who die in mortal
1833 Appen2, 1|       forthwith ~consigned to eternal punishment. Therefore those who die
1834 Appen2, 1|             not deserving of eternal ~punishment, so those who are in mortal
1835 Appen2, 1|              life. For if the debt of punishment is not paid in ~full after
1836 Appen2, 1|            sin be set in order by due punishment, it follows ~that one who
1837 Appen2, 1|               sin, whereas ~sometimes punishment awaits him who dies in charity,
1838 Appen2, 1|              damned punished. For the punishment of the damned is ~eternal,
1839 Appen2, 1|            shall go into everlasting ~punishment [Vulg.: 'fire']." But the
1840 Appen2, 1|                2 Para. 1/1~OBJ 2: The punishment of hell is called by various
1841 Appen2, 1|            winds," etc., whereas the ~punishment of Purgatory is called by
1842 Appen2, 1|           succored, seeing that their punishment being made known to the
1843 Appen2, 1|            Para. 1/1~Reply OBJ 2: The punishment of hell is for the purpose
1844 Appen2, 1|              the chief purpose of the punishment of Purgatory is to cleanse ~