Part, Question
1 1, 25 | that the fact of having sinned ~or having lost charity
2 1, 47 | if a hundred souls had sinned, ~there would be a hundred
3 1, 61 | angels; but only of such as sinned, who, in the opinion of
4 1, 62 | remain?~(8) Could they have sinned afterwards?~(9) After entering
5 1, 63 | considered. In this way the angel sinned, by ~seeking his own good,
6 1, 63 | Without doubt the angel sinned by seeking to be as God. ~
7 1, 63 | whereby the angels who sinned are denoted. Therefore in
8 1, 63 | made blessed, and ~some sinned.~Aquin.: SMT FP Q[63] A[
9 1, 63 | and so would never have sinned, which is false. ~It remains,
10 1, 63 | remains, then, that they sinned by inordinate action in
11 1, 63 | their ~creation, could have sinned, but did not. Yet this view
12 1, 63 | instant wherein the devil sinned was distinct from ~the instant
13 1, 63 | Saints, is that the devil sinned at once after the first
14 1, 63 | highest angel among those who sinned was the highest of all?~
15 1, 63 | highest among the angels who sinned was ~not the highest of
16 1, 63 | highest ~angel among those who sinned was not the highest of all.~
17 1, 63 | the highest of the angels sinned, it ~follows that the Divine
18 1, 63 | seems that the angel who sinned ~was not the highest of
19 1, 63 | that the chief angel ~who sinned, "being set over all the
20 1, 63 | the highest of those who sinned was set over the ~terrestrial
21 1, 63 | Gregory says that he who sinned ~was the very highest of
22 1, 63 | Therefore the first angel who sinned is ~called, not a Seraph,
23 1, 63 | Fide Orth. ii), they all sinned at one time. ~Therefore
24 1, 63 | not appear that the angels sinned by desiring to be ~subject
25 1, 63 | lower angels would have sinned more deeply ~than the highest
26 1, 63 | Although the demons all sinned in the one instant, yet
27 1, 63 | Para. 1/1~Whether those who sinned were as many as those who
28 1, 63 | would seem that more angels sinned than stood firm. For, as ~
29 1, 63 | would appear ~that those who sinned were not from all the orders.~
30 1, 63 | More angels stood firm than sinned. Because sin is ~contrary
31 1, 64 | OBJ 4: The fact that man sinned from another's suggestion,
32 1, 65 | spiritual ~creatures had sinned in the same way as the one
33 1, 72 | injurious to man before man sinned. ~Therefore such animals
34 1, 72 | least not until man had sinned.~Aquin.: SMT FP Q[72] A[
35 1, 72 | And, since man before he sinned would have ~used the things
36 1, 48 | if a hundred souls had sinned, ~there would be a hundred
37 1, 62 | angels; but only of such as sinned, who, in the opinion of
38 1, 63 | remain?~(8) Could they have sinned afterwards?~(9) After entering
39 1, 64 | considered. In this way the angel sinned, by ~seeking his own good,
40 1, 64 | Without doubt the angel sinned by seeking to be as God. ~
41 1, 64 | whereby the angels who sinned are denoted. Therefore in
42 1, 64 | made blessed, and ~some sinned.~Aquin.: SMT FP Q[63] A[
43 1, 64 | and so would never have sinned, which is false. ~It remains,
44 1, 64 | remains, then, that they sinned by inordinate action in
45 1, 64 | their ~creation, could have sinned, but did not. Yet this view
46 1, 64 | instant wherein the devil sinned was distinct from ~the instant
47 1, 64 | Saints, is that the devil sinned at once after the first
48 1, 64 | highest angel among those who sinned was the highest of all?~
49 1, 64 | highest among the angels who sinned was ~not the highest of
50 1, 64 | highest ~angel among those who sinned was not the highest of all.~
51 1, 64 | the highest of the angels sinned, it ~follows that the Divine
52 1, 64 | seems that the angel who sinned ~was not the highest of
53 1, 64 | that the chief angel ~who sinned, "being set over all the
54 1, 64 | the highest of those who sinned was set over the ~terrestrial
55 1, 64 | Gregory says that he who sinned ~was the very highest of
56 1, 64 | Therefore the first angel who sinned is ~called, not a Seraph,
57 1, 64 | Fide Orth. ii), they all sinned at one time. ~Therefore
58 1, 64 | not appear that the angels sinned by desiring to be ~subject
59 1, 64 | lower angels would have sinned more deeply ~than the highest
60 1, 64 | Although the demons all sinned in the one instant, yet
61 1, 64 | Para. 1/1~Whether those who sinned were as many as those who
62 1, 64 | would seem that more angels sinned than stood firm. For, as ~
63 1, 64 | would appear ~that those who sinned were not from all the orders.~
64 1, 64 | More angels stood firm than sinned. Because sin is ~contrary
65 1, 65 | OBJ 4: The fact that man sinned from another's suggestion,
66 1, 66 | spiritual ~creatures had sinned in the same way as the one
67 1, 71 | injurious to man before man sinned. ~Therefore such animals
68 1, 71 | least not until man had sinned.~Aquin.: SMT FP Q[72] A[
69 1, 71 | And, since man before he sinned would have ~used the things
70 1, 93 | was deceived before she sinned in deed, ~still it was not
71 1, 93 | not till she had already sinned by interior pride. For ~
72 1, 93 | reply that man had already ~sinned in his heart, and that he
73 1, 96 | otherwise; for had he not sinned, he would not ~have died.
74 1, 96 | taken food he would have sinned; as he also ~sinned by taking
75 1, 96 | have sinned; as he also ~sinned by taking the forbidden
76 1, 97 | Therefore, even if man had not sinned, ~there would have been
77 1, 99 | to God, while the ~others sinned, were at once confirmed
78 1, 99 | our first ~parents had not sinned, any of their descendants
79 1, 99 | Reply OBJ 1: If Adam had not sinned, he would not have begotten ~"
80 1, 108 | given to the angels who sinned.~Aquin.: SMT FP Q[109] A[
81 1, 108 | superior demons who have sinned the most ~grievously, would
82 1, 113 | this was in as ~far as they sinned through the devil's instigation.
83 2, 72 | respect to those who are sinned against?~(5) Whether sins
84 2, 73 | the position of the person sinned against? ~(10) Whether sin
85 2, 73 | the kinship of a ~person sinned against does not apparently
86 2, 73 | Therefore kinship of the person ~sinned against does not aggravate
87 2, 73 | the part of the person ~sinned against, the sin is made
88 2, 73 | condition of the ~person sinned against does not aggravate
89 2, 73 | condition of ~the person sinned against aggravates the sin.~
90 2, 73 | answer that, The person sinned against is, in a manner,
91 2, 73 | in respect of the person sinned against, may be considered
92 2, 80 | irreparable, because he sinned at no other's suggestion.
93 2, 80 | irremediable, not only because he ~sinned without another's suggestion;
94 2, 81 | woman, and ~not the man, had sinned?~Aquin.: SMT FS Q[81] A[
95 2, 81 | all men ~in whom all have sinned."~Aquin.: SMT FS Q[81] A[
96 2, 81 | place of life, before he sinned, but in the ~place of exile
97 2, 81 | place of exile after he had sinned." But if a man were to be
98 2, 81 | were all in him when he sinned. But those who might be
99 2, 81 | if Eve, and not Adam, had sinned, their children would have ~
100 2, 81 | if Eve, and not Adam, had sinned, their ~children would have
101 2, 81 | 5:12): "In whom all have sinned." Now a man ~pre-exist in
102 2, 81 | if Eve, and not Adam, had sinned, their children would ~have
103 2, 81 | Eve, and not Adam, ~had sinned, their children would contract
104 2, 81 | mother: so that if Eve had sinned, her children would have
105 2, 81 | sin, even if Adam had not sinned.~Aquin.: SMT FS Q[81] A[
106 2, 81 | two, since both of ~them sinned, or rather that it entered
107 2, 81 | entered by a woman, since she sinned ~first. Therefore original
108 2, 81 | if Eve, and not Adam, had sinned, ~their children would not
109 2, 81 | Adam, and not ~Eve, had sinned, they would contract it.~
110 2, 81 | if Eve, and not Adam, had sinned, their ~children would be
111 2, 81 | supposing Adam had not sinned, original sin ~would not
112 2, 83 | 12): "In ~whom all have sinned": whereas it is in the bodily
113 2, 86 | small thing to you ~that you sinned with Beelphegor, and the
114 2, 87 | is just that he who has sinned ~against God in his own
115 2, 87 | A ~man is said to have sinned in his own eternity, not
116 2, 87 | greatness of the person sinned against (thus it is a more
117 2, 87 | said to ~Nathan: I have sinned against the Lord. And Nathan
118 2, 87 | Neither hath ~this man sinned, nor his parents . . . that
119 2, 87 | happens that one ~who has not sinned, bears willingly the punishment
120 2, 87 | somewhat upon those who sinned, as stated above, in so ~
121 2, 96 | 6: "To Thee only have I sinned," a gloss says ~that "there
122 2, 98 | taking occasion from the law, sinned all the ~more, both because
123 2, 98 | immediately after he had sinned. Therefore the Law should ~
124 2, 105 | help her." ~But if a man sinned in any way voluntarily,
125 2, 105 | third degree was when a man ~sinned from pride, i.e. through
126 2, 105 | fourth degree was when a man sinned from stubbornness or obstinacy:
127 2, 106 | 11). But "all" men "have sinned and do need the glory of
128 2, 109 | otherwise he would have sinned. Therefore he loved God
129 2, 113 | thus: "'My son, hast thou sinned? do so no more?' Now ~this
130 2, 5 | it, and in man before he ~sinned, by reason of the manifest
131 2, 5 | confirmed, and man, before he sinned. ~Nevertheless we must observe
132 2, 5 | nor did man ~before he sinned: yet their contemplation
133 2, 5 | in the demons after they sinned.~Aquin.: SMT SS Q[5] A[2]
134 2, 11 | forgiven, as often as he has sinned." Therefore he ought to
135 2, 11 | Church as often as he has sinned by falling back into heresy.~
136 2, 13 | Jews, as though they had sinned against the Holy Ghost,
137 2, 13 | flesh: but afterwards they sinned more grievously when, by
138 2, 13 | cannot do this until he has sinned ~many times; for the Philosopher
139 2, 13 | for a man who ~has never sinned to have the purpose either
140 2, 20 | Sent. ii, D, 22) that "Adam sinned less, because he sinned ~
141 2, 20 | sinned less, because he sinned ~in the hope of pardon,"
142 2, 23 | but cooled." ~But Peter sinned mortally in denying Christ.
143 2, 30 | in respect of the person ~sinned against; and if the sin
144 2, 31 | the sinner, and the person sinned ~against, either because
145 2, 32 | inflicted on the person sinned against. On the ~first count,
146 2, 37 | was no need for those who sinned ~against this faith by falling
147 2, 39 | with ~them: wherefore these sinned, and not the servants of
148 2, 41 | and of ~Paul also, Peter sinned and was to be blamed, in
149 2, 60 | the contrary, He that has sinned is bound to satisfaction.
150 2, 60 | punished except the one who sinned. Therefore none are bound
151 2, 62 | unlawful to kill men who have sinned. For our Lord ~in the parable (
152 2, 62 | lawful to kill a man who has sinned.~Aquin.: SMT SS Q[64] A[
153 2, 62 | good to kill a man who has sinned, even as it is ~to kill
154 2, 62 | individual to kill a man who has ~sinned?~Aquin.: SMT SS Q[64] A[
155 2, 62 | individual to kill a man who ~has sinned. For nothing unlawful is
156 2, 62 | individual to kill a man who has ~sinned.~Aquin.: SMT SS Q[64] A[
157 2, 62 | other hand a ~man who has sinned is not by nature distinct
158 2, 62 | inflicted on the person sinned against. Now to be killed
159 2, 64 | imposed except on one who has sinned. Now it is stated ~(Extra,
160 2, 87 | swear to commit a sin, he sinned ~in swearing, and sins in
161 2, 89 | sung, I confess to have sinned penally, and then had rather ~
162 2, 95 | observes: just as Zachary sinned in saying to the angel (
163 2, 96 | not follow that he has not sinned ~mortally. The reason why
164 2, 97 | the sacred thing that is sinned against, ~the more grievous
165 2, 98 | for a burial ~place, he sinned in selling, though Abraham
166 2, 98 | hated Esau." ~Wherefore Esau sinned by selling his birthright,
167 2, 98 | his birthright, yet Jacob sinned not in ~buying, because
168 2, 106 | penal evil on ~one who has sinned. Accordingly, in the matter
169 2, 106 | because the latter has already sinned against ~him, since this
170 2, 106 | punishment of the person who has sinned ~(for instance that the
171 2, 106 | the ~multitude that has sinned, then if the guilty can
172 2, 106 | taken on those who have sinned involuntarily?~Aquin.: SMT
173 2, 106 | taken on those who have sinned ~involuntarily. For the
174 2, 108 | evidently unlawful, because he sinned in ~promise, and did well
175 2, 152 | mourn many of them /that sinned ~before, and have not done
176 2, 152 | in general, so, too, Osee sinned not in committing ~fornication
177 2, 154 | fact he rejoices in having ~sinned, because the sinful act
178 2, 161 | all other sins?~(4) Which sinned more grievously, the man
179 2, 161 | 1/1~OBJ 3: Further, man sinned at the devil's suggestion.
180 2, 161 | inordinately, neither of them sinned by coveting a ~likeness
181 2, 161 | nature. But the first man sinned chiefly by coveting God'
182 2, 161 | befall him. ~Secondarily he sinned by coveting God's likeness
183 2, 161 | the other hand, ~the devil sinned by coveting God's likeness,
184 2, 161 | circumstances of the persons who sinned, that sin ~was most grave
185 2, 161 | would seem that the woman ~sinned through ignorance, but the
186 2, 161 | commit a sin. Therefore ~Adam sinned more grievously than Eve.~
187 2, 161 | grievous. Now Adam, apparently, sinned against the Holy Ghost,
188 2, 161 | Therefore it seems that Adam ~sinned more grievously than Eve.~
189 2, 161 | from Gn. 3. Therefore she ~sinned more grievously than the
190 2, 161 | considered to ~be equal, for each sinned by pride. Hence Augustine
191 2, 161 | species of pride, the woman sinned more grievously, ~for three
192 2, 161 | the woman not only herself sinned, but ~suggested sin to the
193 2, 161 | to the man; wherefore she sinned against both God and her ~
194 2, 162 | Para. 3/3~If man had not sinned, the earth would have brought
195 2, 163 | to be tempted before he sinned.~Aquin.: SMT SS Q[165] A[
196 2, 184 | Through poverty many have sinned" - but also ~corporal, for
197 2, 184 | her knew to say: 'I have sinned and done evil before Thee.'"
198 2, 184 | these words were addressed, sinned ~not out of contempt, but
199 3, 1 | Whether, if man had not sinned, God would have become incarnate?~
200 3, 1 | seem that if man had not sinned, God would still have ~become
201 3, 1 | Therefore if man had not sinned, God ~would have become
202 3, 1 | Therefore, even if man had not ~sinned, God would have become incarnate.~
203 3, 1 | Therefore, if man had not sinned, human nature would have ~
204 3, 1 | Therefore, if man had not sinned, God would ~have become
205 3, 1 | Therefore, even if man had not sinned, God ~would have become
206 3, 1 | Therefore, if man had not sinned, the Son of ~Man would not
207 3, 1 | that even if man had not sinned, the Son of Man would have ~
208 3, 1 | sin. For if man had not sinned, he ~would have been endowed
209 3, 1 | together, since ~all have sinned and need the glory of God."
210 3, 3 | remedy. For the ~first man sinned by seeking knowledge, as
211 3, 4 | belong to justice that he who sinned should make amends; and
212 3, 15 | that "in Adam all have ~sinned" - namely, because all were
213 3, 15 | by origin. Therefore He sinned in him.~Aquin.: SMT TP Q[
214 3, 15 | example, not by having ~sinned, but by freely bearing the
215 3, 15 | Heal my soul, for I have sinned against Thee." Therefore
216 3, 27 | sanctification was that she never sinned?~(5) Whether in virtue of
217 3, 27 | case with Adam, ~before he sinned, by reason of original justice:
218 3, 27 | of God, if she ~had ever sinned. First, because the honor
219 3, 31 | because in him all nations sinned originally, as is clear
220 3, 31 | Adam ~originally when he sinned: therefore he would have
221 3, 31 | Solomon, in whose mother David sinned; whereas Luke ascends to ~
222 3, 31 | there were other kings who sinned and are ~mentioned in Christ'
223 3, 31 | for ~instance, that Christ sinned in Adam, since after some
224 3, 34 | sinner, because He never sinned; but He was ~made holy from
225 3, 34 | beatitude, they would not have sinned afterwards. Therefore ~Christ,
226 3, 41 | bread, ~He would not have sinned; just as neither did He
227 3, 44 | Neither hath ~this man sinned, nor his parents, that he
228 3, 46 | angelic nature which had sinned. Therefore, apparently, ~
229 3, 46 | mercy: "To Thee only have ~I sinned" (Ps. 50:6), as if to say: "
230 3, 46 | Jews and of the others who ~sinned in His death chiefly of
231 3, 46 | could not suffer, except he sinned. so that he would become
232 3, 47 | His death. But the Jews ~sinned in His death, on whose behalf
233 3, 47 | sinning. The Jews ~therefore sinned, as crucifiers not only
234 3, 47 | also of the common order sinned most ~grievously as to the
235 3, 48 | confess it. But Christ never sinned, according to 1 Pt. 2:22: "
236 3, 48 | because those who slew Him sinned most grievously, as stated ~
237 3, 65 | Heal my soul, for I have sinned against Thee." ~The other
238 3, 70 | beyond the eighth day, ~sinned, even though it were the
239 3, 84 | 12): "In ~whom all have sinned." Nevertheless, Penance
240 3, 84 | Jacob, nor to those ~who sinned not against Thee." But "
241 3, 84 | be ~displeased at having sinned, for if he were to be pleased
242 3, 84 | be displeased at having sinned, and be pleased at his displeasure ~
243 3, 84 | pardoning their brethren who had sinned against them; ~wherefore,
244 3, 85 | 15:21: ~"Father, I have sinned against heaven and before
245 3, 86 | many who ~repent having sinned, but not completely; for
246 3, 86 | said to Nathan: "I have sinned against the Lord," Nathan
247 3, 89 | former dignity after ~having sinned, because this is allowed
248 Suppl, 4 | everlasting punishment, ~and sinned against the eternal God,
249 Suppl, 6 | the fact of his ~having sinned became known to another
250 Suppl, 6 | sinner, because "all have sinned ~and need the grace of God" (
251 Suppl, 7 | innocent ~than one who has sinned. But the confession of a
252 Suppl, 8 | because the greater the person sinned against, the more ~grievous
253 Suppl, 8 | as regards ~the one who sinned, or as regards others: and
254 Suppl, 9 | OTC Para. 2/2~Further, who sinned by himself should, by himself,
255 Suppl, 14| counted from the time when he sinned." But they would not ~be
256 Suppl, 14| contrite as soon as he had ~sinned, and did many good actions
257 Suppl, 32| children, since they have not sinned by sight and hearing; as
258 Suppl, 36| raised already. But Heli sinned ~mortally by not correcting
259 Suppl, 41| virgin marry she ~hath not sinned," and (1 Tim. 5:14): "I
260 Suppl, 43| father sorrowful, for he had sinned in the boy ~through failing
261 Suppl, 47| until it be proved; and he sinned if he said that ~he consented
262 Suppl, 62| although marriage is more sinned against when both are ~guilty
263 Suppl, 62| committing fornication, sinned against ~her husband. Therefore
264 Suppl, 62| although one of them may have sinned more grievously than the
265 Suppl, 64| have happened had she not ~sinned mortally. Therefore, etc.~
266 Suppl, 67| he sent her away, and yet sinned not. Therefore it could ~
267 Suppl, 67| etc. Therefore the wife sinned not by marrying another
268 Suppl, 67| the ~Lord." Therefore she sinned by marrying another husband.~
269 Suppl, 67| mentioned opinion (A[3]), ~she sinned by marrying another husband
270 Suppl, 67| indulgent to one who ~had sinned. Therefore this also was
271 Suppl, 69| in the places where they ~sinned, as Gregory states (Dial.
272 Suppl, 69| Dial. iv, 55). But they sinned in the place ~which we inhabit.
273 Suppl, 71| Now it is clear that they sinned mortally through acting ~
274 Suppl, 71| them by right of war. They sinned, however, venially by ~covetousness:
275 Suppl, 72| regards guilt, since the devil sinned ~there, and as regards natural
276 Suppl, 72| that heaven as soon as they sinned.~Aquin.: SMT XP Q[74] A[
277 Suppl, 84| through the fact that a man ~sinned after receiving grace. In
278 Suppl, 85| 2:12): "Whosoever have sinned in ~the Law shall be judged
279 Suppl, 86| OBJ 2: Further, the demons sinned more grievously than men.
280 Suppl, 86| to the devil for ~having sinned, and yet it is unjust for
281 Suppl, 86| spared not the angels ~that sinned, but delivered them drawn
282 Suppl, 88| night." ~Therefore when man sinned the heavenly bodies were
283 Suppl, 88| should deteriorate when he sinned, or that it should be ~bettered
284 Suppl, 93| continence. If Adam had not sinned, ~virginity would have had
285 Suppl, 93| angels, since they never sinned. Therefore an aureole is
286 Suppl, 93| in the flesh and who have sinned at some ~time.~Aquin.: SMT
287 Suppl, 94| 17). But the wicked have sinned on the earth. ~Therefore
288 Suppl, 94| the souls of the departed sinned through love of the flesh,
289 Suppl, 94| for as much as man having sinned in soul ~and body will be
290 Suppl, 94| the very place where he sinned, because the place due to ~
291 Suppl, 95| Further, to wish one had not sinned is a good will. But the ~
292 Suppl, 95| never wish ~they had not sinned: and thus the same conclusion
293 Suppl, 95| choice ~whereby he previously sinned [*Cf. FP, Q[64], A[2]].
294 Suppl, 95| OBJ 2: To wish one had not sinned on account of the shamefulness ~
295 Suppl, 96| the dignity of the person sinned against, so that a person ~
296 Suppl, 96| sin. One is because ~they sinned against an eternal good
297 Suppl, 96| Another reason is because man sinned in his own eternity [*Cf.
298 Suppl, 96| from the fact that he has sinned against ~God the author
299 Appen1, 2| state Adam would not have sinned venially, as ~was stated (
300 Appen2, 1| the very places where they sinned." ~And Gregory relates (
|