|
I
Buddhism
has, throughout its history, slowly moved east, from India through China,
Burma, Thailand, Vietnam, Korea, Japan. Most recently, it has begun its jump
across the ocean to the United States. With each move, the expression of
Buddhism has changed to suit the culture of the people. Buddhism has not yet
been in the United States (or any other Western country) long enough to develop
into a clear new form, suitable for Western culture. There are many aspects of
traditional Buddhism which need slight adaptation in order to be accepted
within the complex structures of Western society. One of the areas of
traditional Buddhism which modern Western Buddhists find the most problematic
is the area of gender. In most Asian Buddhist traditions, the leaders and
teachers are all male, while females are given less prestigious roles. Western
Buddhists tend to come from highly educated and socially liberal backgrounds,
which means that they tend to feel that men and women are equal and should be
given equal opportunities in all endeavors. This difference of opinion between
Western and Asian Buddhists causes a certain amount of tension.
As
a female Western Buddhist, I am naturally extremely interested in this issue.
While admittedly it may have little bearing upon men's practice on Buddhism, it
has the potential to have an enormous effect upon my practice of Buddhism. I
decided to use the opportunity this paper presented me to examine the role of
women in Theravada Buddhism. Theravada is the oldest and most traditional of
the various sects of Buddhism being imported to the United States. In order to
understand the current situation, it is necessary to understand the historical
setting. Therefore, I thought I would start by examining the role of women in
early Buddhism, and trace the historical role of women in Theravada Buddhism
through to the present.
What,
then, was the role of women at the time of the Buddha? The historical Buddha
lived in northern India at approximately 500 BCE. Women seem to have held an
extremely subordinate place in the society in which he lived. They spent their
lives serving. A typical woman spent her youth serving and obeying her parents,
her middle years serving and obeying her husband and his parents, and her old
age serving and obeying her grown children. Women usually had to marry the
husband chosen for them by their parents, although occasionally young women would
be given the choice of several suitors. The literature also mentions occasional
elopements, without the permission of parents. However, for the most part,
daughters could be married off at the discretion of their fathers.
Once
married, women were supposed to obey their husband and his parents. Wives
cooked, cleaned, bore and raised children, and looked after the servants. Women
ate only what was left after the men had finished eating. If a husband was
displeased with his wife, he could beat her or throw her out of the house.
Divorce could be initiated by the husband, but not the wife. Women were
supposed to bear children for their husbands. If no children were forthcoming,
the husband would often take another wife. Adulterous wives were punished with
death, while adulterous husbands were not punished at all. There were instances
in which husbands would give their wives away to other men. Women were lowered
nearly to the point of being mere chattel.
There
were, of course, some women who were courtesans or prostitutes. Some women
chose this life for themselves. Others had less choice. It is recorded that in
Vaisali, there was a law forbidding a perfect woman to marry, and demanding
that she be made available for the pleasures of the people. There were both advantages
and disadvantages to the life of a courtesan. Courtesans often learned to play
music and to dance. They were relatively independent, and could earn their own
living. They had an accepted place in society. However, their lives were
unsafe. As they had no one protecting them, they easily fell victim to robbers
and murderers.
Many
women were lower-class servants or slaves. These women had to follow all of the
orders of their masters. Most of them worked hard all day, everyday. They could
not marry without the permission of their masters. The slave women did not have
the right to refuse the sexual advances of their masters. If the masters chose,
they could beat the slave women to death. There are instances recorded in which
slave women were beaten so regularly and heartlessly by their masters that they
committed suicide.
In
all their roles, women were less powerful than were men. As Janice Willis says,
"They
were helpmates at best and burdens at worst, but always they were viewed as being
inferior, second class citizens." 1
Women
seldom were allowed to make their own decisions. They were told what to do by
men and spent their lives in service to others.
This,
then, is the society in which the Buddha grew up and taught. Into this culture,
the Buddha made what would have then been a radical statement on the potential
of women. When asked by Ananda (his closest disciple) the Buddha said that
women are capable of becoming arhats. If women follow the path of renunciation,
they can become completely enlightened, just as men can. Elsewhere in the
scriptures, the Buddha elaborates on this idea, while using the imagery of a
chariot to explain the Buddhist path:
"
'Straight' is the name that Road is called, and 'Free From Fear' the Quarter
whither thou art bound. Thy Chariot is the 'Silent Runner' named, With
Wheels of Righteous Effort fitted well. Conscience the Leaning-board; the
Drapery Is Heedfulness; the Driver is the Dharma, I say, and Right Views, they
that run before. And be it woman, or be it man for whom Such a chariot
doth wait, by that same car into Nirvana's presence shall they come." 2
Thus
we find the Buddha teaching that not only can women reach the same levels of
enlightenment as can men, but women also follow the same path to get there. The
Buddha does not say that there are no differences between men and women.
However, in these statements, he seems to feel that any differences between men
and women are unimportant in the pursuit liberation.
|