Table of Contents | Words: Alphabetical - Frequency - Inverse - Length - Statistics | Help | IntraText Library
Antonio A. Borelli
Fatima: past or future?

IntraText CT - Text

  • INTRODUCTION
Previous - Next

Click here to hide the links to concordance

INTRODUCTION

In books about Fatima, the narration of the apparitions and the conversations of Our Lady with the seers are usually not the primary focus; instead these are intermixed with other related events and aspects of the story, such as the local repercussions of the apparitions, the interrogations of the seers and witnesses, the cures and extraordinary conversions that followed, the fascinating details of the spiritual progress of the privileged children, and numerous associated episodes. All of this is perfectly natural and understandable.

Nevertheless, after reading these books, many feel a desire for a text that would devote special attention to the contents of the apparitions. They seek to more fully grasp the meaning of the message Our Lady came to communicate to men and thus heed her admonitions.

To satisfy this legitimate desire, we have attempted to put together a story centred on what occurred between the Virgin and the seers; and between the Angel of Portugal and the seers. The numerous edifying and picturesque facts interwoven with the story of Fatima have been set aside in order to focus attention on this essential part.

The accounts of the apparitions of the angel in 1916 and Our Lady in 1917 are followed by private revelations received by the seers, especially Sister Lucia. Since they complement the apparitions at Cova da Iria, they could not be omitted here.

The first edition of this work in 1967 was based primarily on two well-known works, which we recommend to those who are anxious to read more about the story of Fatima. One is William Thomas Walsh's Our Lady of Fatima; the other, Era uma Senhora mais brillante que o sol by Father John M. de Marchi, I.M.C. (See bibliography).

Father De Marchi spent several years in Fatima, questioning witnesses of the events and carefully recording their remarks. He interviewed Sister Lucia and was able to examine her manuscripts, which we shall discuss further on.

In 1946, William Thomas Walsh also went to Portugal to interview witnesses and do research. He spoke with Sister Lucia and relied extensively on her four memoirs in the writing of his book.

The works of Father De Marchi and Walsh are well researched and in essential agreement in most details. Nevertheless, further care was taken to compare them with books of other authors, who complete and clarify certain facts and details. These are pointed out in their proper places. Unfortunately, it was then impossible to examine the authoritative sources themselves, the manuscripts of Sister Lucia. Those manuscripts had not yet been published, save for a few excerpts reproduced by several authors who had been able to examine them.

When the first edition was published on the occasion of the fiftieth anniversary of the apparitions, we expressed the desire to see the complete text of those precious manuscripts brought to light for the edification of all those who are devoted to Our Lady of Fatima. Today it behoves us to acknowledge the fulfilment of this desire. The manuscripts were at last published in 1973 by Father Antonio Maria Martins, S.J. in Memórias e Cartas da Irmã Lúcia.

However, we are still eagerly awaiting a complete work1 that, in addition to the memoirs and letters already published, contains all the interrogations to which Sister Lucia was subjected, the documents of the canonical investigation, 2 and all the seer's correspondence that still exists. 3 The importance of the Fatima message certainly warrants such a meritorious effort.

The four accounts Sister Lucia wrote are usually designated as Memoirs I, II, III, and IV. (The remaining parts of Father Antonio Maria Martins' book are referred to here simply as Memoirs.)

Memoir I is a collection of Sister Lucia's reminiscences for a biography of Jacinta. On 12 September 1935, the mortal remains of the little seer of Fatima, who died in 1920, were exhumed. Her face was found to be incorrupt. The Rt. Rev. José Alves Correia da Silva, Bishop of Leiria, sent Sister Lucia a photograph taken on this occasion. In her letter of thanks, she referred to the virtues of her cousin. The prelate then ordered her to write all she knew about the life of Jacinta. Thus, the task of writing the first manuscript began. It was finished around Christmas 1935.

In April of 1937, Father Ayres da Fonseca told the Bishop of Leiria that Sister Lucia's first account suggested the existence of yet unknown facts related to the apparitions. This prompted a new order from the bishop for Sister Lucia to write the story of her life, a task she accomplished between 7 and 21 November of the same year. In this account she also speaks, although very briefly, of the apparitions of Our Lady and, for the first time, officially discloses the apparitions of the Angel of Portugal. Until then, she had remained silent about them for several reasons: She had been advised to do so by the archpriest of Olival, Father Faustino José Jacinto Ferreira (to whom she had narrated the apparitions), later reinforced by the same recommendation from the Bishop of Leiria; additionally, the criticism and mockery resulting from her account of the three apparitions of the angel in the spring and summer of 1916 and the severe reprimands of her mother always prompted her to great caution and discretion. But Sister Lucia's great reluctance to talk about herself and, therefore, about the apparitions in her memoirs still mystifies the reader.

In 1941, the Bishop of Leiria again ordered the seer to provide, to the best of her ability, a detailed narrative of Jacinta's life for a book being written by Canon José Galamba de Oliveira about the youngest seer. "This order," writes Sister Lucia, "touched the depth of my soul like a beam of light telling me that the time had come to reveal the first two parts of the secret...." 4 Thus, Sister Lucia began her third manuscript by revealing the currently known parts of the secret of Fatima. Following this, she recorded the impression these revelations had made on Jacinta. This account is dated 31 August 1941.

Surprised by such revelations, Canon Galamba de Oliveira concluded that Sister Lucia had not told everything in her previous accounts and urged the Bishop of Leiria to command her to write the complete story of the apparitions. "Your Excellencygive her the order to write everything, and I mean everything. She will have to wander a while in purgatory for staying silent about so many things." Sister Lucia excused herself, saying that she always acted out of obedience. Canon Galamba de Oliveira insisted that the bishop order her "to tell everything, everything; she should hide nothing". (He was apparently alluding to the third part of the secret.) The bishop, however, chose not to become involved. "That I shall not order. In secret matters, I shall not meddle." Instead, he simply told the seer to make a complete narration of the apparitions. 5 Then she wrote the fourth manuscript, which bears the date of 8 December 1941. In this memoir, Sister Lucia, for the first time gave a systematic and ordered account of the apparitions, stating in the conclusion of the narrative that nothing of all that she could remember had been "knowingly" omitted, save, evidently, the third part of the secret, which she had not been ordered to reveal. 6

 

In June 1943 Sister Lucia fell ill with pleurisy that lasted for several months, during which time she would sometimes improve and sometimes have relapses. This was further complicated by the side effects of the medicine she was taking.

 

Fearing the worst, the Bishop of Leiria, after much hesitation, in the middle of September of that year, asked the seer to write the third part of the Secret. It was a request and not an order. As a result, the seer was left in a state of perplexity, because she did not feel moved to do this by any interior grace. In mid-October, the Bishop of Leiria gave the explicit order she had requested, but, nonetheless, the seer was unable to overcome her interior anguish.

 

Having been consulted about this, Bishop Antônio Garcia, apostolic administrator of Tuy and Archbishop-designate of Valladolid, suggested she explain her difficulties to the Bishop of Leiria. But the Superioress of Sister Lucia retained his letter to the seer, dated early December, until mid-January.

 

However, before the letter was delivered to Sister Lucia, Our Lady dispelled all of her doubts on 2 January 1944. Our Lady appeared to her in the infirmary of the House of the Doretheans in Tuy and ordered her to write what was requested of her. The seer did so the very next day. 7

 

This document’s long itinerary of having been given to the Bishop of Leiria five months later until its revelation in the year 2000 will be dealt with in detail in Chapter II of this work.

 

In the first edition of this work in 1967, we tried to reconstruct the development of the apparitions with the greatest possible fidelity, using the principal bibliographical sources then available. Unfortunately, discrepancies among the best authors were found. Many doubts were settled with the publication of the manuscripts of Sister Lucia, but some still linger. Accordingly, a consultation with the surviving seer is still desirable so that she may clarify the ambiguities wherever possible.

 

In offering this latest edition to the public, we hope to contribute toward making the message of Our Lady of Fatima more widely known, loved, and observed.

 




1 This desire has been realised. The first two volumes of an excellent critical analysis was published by the Santuário de Fátima in a collection entitled Documentação Crítica de Fátima. The first volume (published in 1992) mainly contains the interrogations of the seers at the time of the apparitions. Among these we note those of the parish priest of Fatima, Fr. Manuel Marques Ferreira, and those of Dr. Manuel Nunes Formigão of the patriarchal see of Lisbon, as well as the investigation of the Fatima parish that lasted until 1919. The second volume (published in 1999) concentrates on the Diocesan investigation that closed in 1930. Over the years, Dr. Manuel Nunes Formigão also published several books on the subject under the pseudonym of Visconde de Montelo.

Furthermore, in his book A Vidente de Fatima dialoga e responde pelas Aparições, Father Sebastião Martins dos Reis presents (a) the interrogation made by Father H. I. Iongen, a Dutch Montfortist who visited with Sister Lucia on 3 and 4 February 1946, and published an account of these interviews in the May, July, and October, 1946, issues of the bimonthly review Mediatrice et Reine; (b) the identification of the historic places of Fatima by the seer on 20 May 1946; (c) the interrogation by Dr. J. J. Goulven, which was answered in writing by Sister Lucia on 30 June 1946 (Father Sebastião Martins dos Reis relates that Sister Lucia sent the manuscript to the Bishop of Leiria, who in turn ordered that it be typewritten and that three copies be made. After being signed by the seer, one of the copies was sent to Dr. Goulven, another remained with the seer, and the third was filed with the original by order of the Bishop of Leiria. The author does not specify whether he transcribed the document from the manuscript or one of the copies.); and (d) the interrogation by Father José Pedro da Silva (later Bishop of Viseu), answered by the seer on 1 August 1947.

Besides these testimonies and the aforementioned interviews granted to Father De Marchi and Mr. Walsh, Sister Lucia granted another interview over a period of five days (16 through 20 September 1935) to the writer Antero de Figueiredo. The seer comments on this interview in her own writings. (Memoir IV, pp. 368-376)



2 After eight years of thorough enquiry, the canonical process of investigation concluded in favor of the apparitions. In a pastoral letter dated October 13, 1930, The Rt. Rev. José Alves Correia da Silva, Bishop of Leiria, declared: "In virtue of the considerations set forth, and others which for the sake of brevity we omit, humbly invoking the divine Holy Ghost and trusting in the protection of Mary Most Holy, and after hearing the reverend advisers of this our diocese, we hereby (1) declare the visions the children had at Cova da Iria, parish of Fatima, of this diocese, on the thirteenth day of the months of May to October, worthy of belief; and (2) officially permit the cult of Our Lady of Fatima." (Rendeiro, pp. 179-180.)



3 In Memórias e Cartas da Irmã Lúcia, Father Antonio Maria Martins, S.J. includes letters from the seer to her confessor. Father Jose Bernardo Gonçalves, S.J., and points out that it was Father Gonçalves who "later became responsible for the seer's most valuable correspondence.

"Most of these letters deal with matters of conscience. That is why they cannot be published now." (Memoirs, p. 399)

On page xx of the book's preface, Father Martins says that besides the memoirs, the writings of the seer include "thousands of letters, most of them written after her admission to the Carmel of Saint Teresa in Coimbra, on 25 March1948".

In a letter to Father Gonçalves of 21 January 1940, Sister Lucia tells about the censorship her correspondence underwent and how this prevented or made it difficult for her to discuss matters of conscience with him. She says: "I have wanted to write Your Reverence for a long time, but several reasons have impeded it, the main one being censorship. To write while not being able to say what I had to seemed to me a waste of your time; to write it under censorship was impossible. At times the necessity was not small, but (we must have) patience. All has passed, and Our Lord has taken care of everything. As He has sent the wound, so has He sent the cure. He knows very well that He is the only doctor on earth. In fact, I must confess I also doubted that Your Reverence would be willing to waste time on me. So I thank Your Reverence immensely for the letter and for the charity Your Reverence has practiced with me in opening my way. May Our Lord reward Your Reverence." (Memoirs, p. 418)



4 Memoirs, p. 444



5 Memoir IV, pp. 314 and 316



6 Memoir IV, pp. 316 and 352



7 Fr. Joaquín María Alonso, La verdad sobre el secreto de Fátima, pp. 29-36; Canon Sebastião Martins dos Reis, O Milagre do Sol e o Segredo de Fátima, p. 121; Fr. Antonio Maria Martins, S.J., Novos documentos de Fátima, pp. XXV-XXVI, footnote 25.






Previous - Next

Table of Contents | Words: Alphabetical - Frequency - Inverse - Length - Statistics | Help | IntraText Library

Best viewed with any browser at 800x600 or 768x1024 on Tablet PC
IntraText® (V89) - Some rights reserved by EuloTech SRL - 1996-2007. Content in this page is licensed under a Creative Commons License