We live in
a world dominated by the West and by Western ideas. We admire those ideas and
admit to their power. But there must be a way for us to do so, without
betraying our own history. We must summon Clio to speak her truth, which is
stronger than any power.
There is another factor at
work here. Besides writing history, the West has also long dictated
preferences. The interest taken in the Eastern Roman Empire and its Church by
Renaissance scholars may have been lop-sided even condescending - but at least
we were considered a legitimate field of study. But then came the Enlightenment,
which made it fashionable to look down on anything "eastern" or
"spiritual".
Voltaire called Byzantine
history "nothing but declamations and miracles ...a disgrace to the human
mind" - while Gibbon described the later Roman Empire as the "triumph
of barbarism and religion". The Enlightenment set the stage for the
national revolutions of the nineteenth century, and its any-clerical tone
influenced all of them.
|