1015-octob | offic-world
Part, Paragraph
1 Note, 1(4) | PS, 1995), 8th edition, 1015 pp. [Italian trans. Manuale
2 Note, 1(22)| 78, 82, 89-90, 94-95, 98, 102, 116, 120, 130-131, 136,
3 Note, 1(13)| 107-108 and in Ma I, 99 = 103 in reference to Sacred Scripture;
4 Note, 2(38)| Ad splendidum nitentis (1054): DS 687-688.~
5 Note, 1(13)| 148; Ma III, 99-100 = 107-108 and in Ma I, 99 = 103
6 Note, 1(13)| 148; Ma III, 99-100 = 107-108 and in Ma I, 99 = 103 in
7 Note, 2(44)| Encyclical Letter Humanae vitae, 11-14: AAS 60 (1968), 488-491.~
8 Note, 1(4) | Cittadella Editrice, 1997), 1123 pp.].~
9 Note, 1(22)| 89-90, 94-95, 98, 102, 116, 120, 130-131, 136, 167.
10 Note, 1(11)| AAS 85 (1993), 1162-1163, 1166-1169.~
11 Note, 1(12)| splendor, 44: AAS 85 (1993), 1168-1169. ~
12 Note, 2(46)| 1981), 32: AAS 74 (1982), 118-120; Catechism of the Catholic
13 Note, 1(22)| 94-95, 98, 102, 116, 120, 130-131, 136, 167. See also
14 Note, 1(22)| 102, 116, 120, 130-131, 136, 167. See also Ma I, 80,
15 Note, 1(13)| is found in Ma II/1, 131= 140 and 139 = 148; Ma III, 99-
16 Note, 1(22)| Cittadella Editrice, 1994), 142-145: these pages on the
17 Note, 1(6) | cf. Ma I, 139, 211-215 = 147-148, 222-226.~
18 Note, 1(22)| also Ma I, 80, 145= 82-83, 154; Det, 362-365; in addition,
19 Note, 1(22)| 1990), 16: AAS 82 (1990), 1557. In this regard, see: La
20 Note, 1(22)| Veritatis (May 24, 1990), 16: AAS 82 (1990), 1557. In
21 Note, 1(22)| 116, 120, 130-131, 136, 167. See also Ma I, 80, 145=
22 Note, 2(27)| abortu procurato (November 18, 1974), 12-13: AAS 66 (1974),
23 Note, 1(21)| 550-551, 660-661; Ma II/2, 189, 191, 263, 264, 495 = 202,
24 Note, 2(57)| Declaration De abortu procurato, 19-23: AAS 66 (1974), 742-744;
25 Note, 1(21)| 660-661; Ma II/2, 189, 191, 263, 264, 495 = 202, 204,
26 Note, 1(15)| Ma I, 192-193 = 202-203.~
27 Note, 2(34)| Persona humana (December 29, 1975), 8: AAS 68 (1976), 84-85;
28 Note, 2(46)| consortio (November 22, 1981), 32: AAS 74 (1982), 118-
29 Note, 2(46)| November 22, 1981), 32: AAS 74 (1982), 118-120; Catechism of
30 Note, 2(47)| 1987), II, B, 5 AAS 80 (1988) 92–94.~
31 Note, 1(3) | Assisi: Cittadella Editrice, 1996), 748 pp.].~
32 Pre | eschatology – utopia). ~On June 4, 1998, Father Vidal provided his
33 Note, 2(38)| Catholic Church, 2352; >small 1Leo IX, Letter Ad splendidum
34 Pre | Congregation on January 20, 1999, which also decided
35 Note, 1(6) | 266 = 283; cf. Ma I, 139, 211-215 = 147-148, 222-226.~
36 Note, 1(9) | Ma I, 213=224.~
37 Note, 1(6) | 283; cf. Ma I, 139, 211-215 = 147-148, 222-226.~
38 Note, 1(6) | 139, 211-215 = 147-148, 222-226.~
39 Note, 1(9) | Ma I, 213=224.~
40 Note, 2(26)| in some cases, and Det, 225, where it is stated that
41 Note, 1(6) | 211-215 = 147-148, 222-226.~
42 Note, 2(57)| De abortu procurato, 19-23: AAS 66 (1974), 742-744;
43 Note, 2(38)| of the Catholic Church, 2352; >small 1Leo IX, Letter
44 Note, 2(34)| of the Catholic Church, 2357-2359, 2396.~
45 Note, 2(34)| the Catholic Church, 2357-2359, 2396.~
46 Note, 2(46)| Catechism of the Catholic Church 2370, 2399. See also Ma II/2,
47 Note, 2(34)| Catholic Church, 2357-2359, 2396.~
48 Note, 1(22)| PPC, 1994) especially 24-26, 29, 54, 76-78, 82, 89-90,
49 Note, 1(21)| 661; Ma II/2, 189, 191, 263, 264, 495 = 202, 204, 311,
50 Note, 1(21)| Ma II/2, 189, 191, 263, 264, 495 = 202, 204, 311, 312,
51 Note, 2(34)| Cf. Rom 1: 24-27; 1 Cor 6:10; 1 Tm 1:10;
52 Note, 1(16)| Ma I, 274 = 291.~
53 Note, 1(19)| Ma I, 275 =291.~
54 Pre | Congregation. On September 28, 1999, the Superior General
55 Note, 2(32)| Ma II/2, 281-282 = 330.~
56 Note, 2(32)| Ma II/2, 281-282 = 330.~
57 Note, 1(7) | 260 = 276; cf. Ma I, 260-284 = 276-301.~
58 Note, 1(18)| Cf. Ma I, 268-270 = 285-287.~
59 Note, 1(18)| Cf. Ma I, 268-270 = 285-287.~
60 Note, 2(30)| 2, 268 = 316; also Det, 294-295.~
61 Note, 2(30)| 268 = 316; also Det, 294-295.~
62 Note, 2(34)| problema (October 1, 1987), 3-8: AAS 79 (1987), 544-548;
63 Pre | the Faith before September 30, 1999. ~Informed of this
64 Note, 1(7) | cf. Ma I, 260-284 = 276-301.~
65 Note, 1(21)| 263, 264, 495 = 202, 204, 311, 312, 553.~
66 Note, 1(21)| 264, 495 = 202, 204, 311, 312, 553.~
67 Note, 2(28)| Cf. Ma II/2, 266-267 = 314-315.~
68 Note, 2(31)| 316; cf. 268-270 = 316-318.~
69 Note, 2(46)| consortio (November 22, 1981), 32: AAS 74 (1982), 118-120;
70 Note, 2(35)| Ma II/2, 324 = 374.~
71 Note, 1(22)| 80, 145= 82-83, 154; Det, 362-365; in addition, see the
72 Note, 1(22)| 145= 82-83, 154; Det, 362-365; in addition, see the Italian
73 Note, 2(35)| Ma II/2, 324 = 374.~
74 Note, 2(36)| Ma II/2, 330 = 381; cf. Det, 45.~
75 Note, 2(37)| Ma II/2, 332 = 382.~
76 Pre | eschatology – utopia). ~On June 4, 1998, Father Vidal provided
77 Note, 1(21)| 839, 872, 904; Ma II/1, 400-403, 497, 597= 434-437,
78 Note, 2(56)| Ma II/1, 408 = 442 (and 444).~
79 Note, 1(11)| Veritatis splendor, 36, 42-45: AAS 85 (1993), 1162-
80 Note, 1(21)| II/1, 400-403, 497, 597= 434-437, 550-551, 660-661; Ma
81 Note, 2(53)| Cf. Ma II/1, 403 = 437-438.~
82 Note, 1(12)| Letter Veritatis splendor, 44: AAS 85 (1993), 1168-1169. ~
83 Note, 2(56)| Ma II/1, 408 = 442 (and 444).~
84 Note, 2(56)| Ma II/1, 408 = 442 (and 444).~
85 Note, 1(17)| Ma I, 452 = 476.~
86 Note, 2(27)| 1995), 58: AAS 87 (1995), 466-467. On direct sterilization,
87 Note, 2(27)| 58: AAS 87 (1995), 466-467. On direct sterilization,
88 Note, 1(23)| Cf. for example Ma I, 468 = 492.~
89 Note, 1(17)| Ma I, 452 = 476.~
90 Note, 2(57)| vitae, 71-74: AAS 87 (1995), 483-488. ~
91 Note, 1(23)| for example Ma I, 468 = 492.~
92 Note, 1(21)| II/2, 189, 191, 263, 264, 495 = 202, 204, 311, 312, 553.~
93 Note, 1(21)| 904; Ma II/1, 400-403, 497, 597= 434-437, 550-551,
94 Note, 1(22)| 1994) especially 24-26, 29, 54, 76-78, 82, 89-90, 94-95,
95 Note, 2(34)| 1987), 3-8: AAS 79 (1987), 544-548; Catechism of the Catholic
96 Note, 2(34)| 3-8: AAS 79 (1987), 544-548; Catechism of the Catholic
97 Note, 1(21)| 403, 497, 597= 434-437, 550-551, 660-661; Ma II/2, 189,
98 Note, 1(21)| 497, 597= 434-437, 550-551, 660-661; Ma II/2, 189,
99 Note, 1(21)| 495 = 202, 204, 311, 312, 553.~
100 Note, 2(46)| 2399. See also Ma II/2, 571-573 = 648-650.~
101 Note, 2(46)| 2399. See also Ma II/2, 571-573 = 648-650.~
102 Note, 2(26)| 641 = 714; cf. Ma II/2, 575 = 652, which considers sterilization
103 Note, 2(43)| Cf. Ma II/2, 576-577 = 653-654.~
104 Note, 2(27)| vitae (March 25, 1995), 58: AAS 87 (1995), 466-467.
105 Note, 2(50)| Cf. Ma II/1, 586 = 649 and Det, 315.~
106 Note, 2(26)| Ma II/1, 641 = 714; cf. Ma II/2, 575 =
107 Note, 2(46)| also Ma II/2, 571-573 = 648-650.~
108 Note, 2(46)| also Ma II/2, 571-573 = 648-650.~
109 Note, 2(26)| 714; cf. Ma II/2, 575 = 652, which considers sterilization
110 Note, 2(43)| Ma II/2, 576-577 = 653-654.~
111 Note, 1(3) | PS, 1991), 8th edition, 662 pp. [Italian trans. Manuale
112 Note, 2(38)| splendidum nitentis (1054): DS 687-688.~
113 Note, 2(38)| nitentis (1054): DS 687-688.~
114 Note, 2(57)| Letter Evangelium vitae, 71-74: AAS 87 (1995), 483-488. ~
115 Note, 2(26)| Ma II/1, 641 = 714; cf. Ma II/2, 575 = 652,
116 Note, 2(27)| 12-13: AAS 66 (1974), 737-739; John Paul II, Encyclical
117 Note, 2(27)| 13, 1974), AAS 68 (1976), 738-740; Catechism of the Catholic
118 Note, 2(27)| 12-13: AAS 66 (1974), 737-739; John Paul II, Encyclical
119 Note, 2(27)| 1974), AAS 68 (1976), 738-740; Catechism of the Catholic
120 Note, 2(57)| procurato, 19-23: AAS 66 (1974), 742-744; Encyclical Letter Evangelium
121 Note, 2(57)| 19-23: AAS 66 (1974), 742-744; Encyclical Letter Evangelium
122 Note, 1(3) | Cittadella Editrice, 1996), 748 pp.].~
123 Note, 1(22)| especially 24-26, 29, 54, 76-78, 82, 89-90, 94-95, 98,
124 Note, 1(22)| especially 24-26, 29, 54, 76-78, 82, 89-90, 94-95, 98, 102,
125 Note, 1(21)| for example, Ma I, 260, 789-790, 816, 848 =276, 837-
126 Note, 2(34)| October 1, 1987), 3-8: AAS 79 (1987), 544-548; Catechism
127 Note, 1(21)| example, Ma I, 260, 789-790, 816, 848 =276, 837-839,
128 Note, 1(2) | PS, 1991), 8th edition, 797 pp. [Italian trans. Manuale
129 Note, 1(21)| example, Ma I, 260, 789-790, 816, 848 =276, 837-839, 872,
130 Note, 1(22)| See also Ma I, 80, 145= 82-83, 154; Det, 362-365; in addition,
131 Note, 1(21)| 789-790, 816, 848 =276, 837-839, 872, 904; Ma II/1,
132 Note, 1(21)| 790, 816, 848 =276, 837-839, 872, 904; Ma II/1, 400-
133 Note, 2(34)| 1975), 8: AAS 68 (1976), 84-85; Letter Homosexualitatis
134 Note, 1(21)| Ma I, 260, 789-790, 816, 848 =276, 837-839, 872, 904;
135 Note, 1(21)| 816, 848 =276, 837-839, 872, 904; Ma II/1, 400-403,
136 Note, 1(22)| 24-26, 29, 54, 76-78, 82, 89-90, 94-95, 98, 102, 116,
137 Note, 1(2) | Cittadella Editrice, 1995), 896 pp.].~
138 Note, 1(22)| 26, 29, 54, 76-78, 82, 89-90, 94-95, 98, 102, 116, 120,
139 Note, 1(1) | and completely revised), 902 pp. [Italian trans. Manuale
140 Note, 1(21)| 848 =276, 837-839, 872, 904; Ma II/1, 400-403, 497,
141 Note, 2(47)| II, B, 5 AAS 80 (1988) 92–94.~
142 Note, 1(22)| 54, 76-78, 82, 89-90, 94-95, 98, 102, 116, 120, 130-
143 Note, 1(1) | Cittadella Editrice, 1994), 958 pp.]. In the following notes,
144 Note, 1(22)| 76-78, 82, 89-90, 94-95, 98, 102, 116, 120, 130-131,
145 Note, 2 | before implantation, are not abortifacient. He maintains that, generally
146 | about
147 | above
148 Note, 1 | evil actions and on the absolute value of the norms that
149 Note, 2 | becoming heterosexual or total abstinence”.33 These positions are
150 Note, 2 | to create an ‘objective abstraction’ from personal conditioning
151 Note, 1 | practical level, he does not accept the traditional doctrine
152 Pre | Vidal, who manifested his acceptance by affixing his signature. ~
153 Pre | of the case, Father Vidal accepted the doctrinal judgment formulated
154 Note, 1 | kind of world-view which accompanies” those contents.13 Only
155 Pre | new documentation with an accompanying letter were presented to
156 Pre | of the Congregation, in accordance with the Regulations for
157 Note, 1 | foundation of ethics is acknowledged insofar as it “re-contextualizes
158 Note, 2 | teaching, according to which acts of autoeroticism are objectively
159 Note, 1(13)| This then has led to an actual denial that there exists,
160 Note, 2(38)| small 1Leo IX, Letter Ad splendidum nitentis (1054):
161 Note, 1(13)| truly ‘objective,’ that is, adapted to the concrete historical
162 Note, 1(22)| Veritatis splendor were added after the Spanish edition
163 Pre | to grant Father Vidal an additional three month period in which
164 Note, 2 | homosexuality, the author adds, one must “adopt a provisional
165 Pre | and that he had stated his adherence to the teaching of the Magisterium
166 Note, 2 | indirect abortion”, or if he admits the lawfulness of procedures
167 Note, 2 | the author adds, one must “adopt a provisional attitude”,
168 Note, 2 | the present Notification, adopted in the Ordinary Session
169 Note, 2 | abortion. The author rightly affirms the overall immorality of
170 Pre | manifested his acceptance by affixing his signature. ~This resolution
171 | against
172 Pre | assent and confirmed the agreed-upon procedure, that is, the
173 Pre | Father Vidal in a meeting aimed at obtaining explicit recognition
174 Pre | las “Preguntas dirigidas al Rev. P. Marciano Vidal,
175 | almost
176 | alone
177 Note, 1 | personalism of political alterity”.19~The Christian ethic
178 | Although
179 | always
180 | Among
181 Note, 1(3) | Actitudes, II/2: Moral del amor y de la sexualidad (Madrid:
182 Note, 1(3) | teologica, II-2a: Morale dell’amore e della sessualità (Assisi:
183 | another
184 Pre | obtain more exact and precise answers, were communicated to Father
185 Pre | Congregation, the Most Reverend Antonio Cañizares Llovera, Archbishop
186 | any
187 Note, 2 | Feast of the Chair of Peter, Apostle.~ ~+ Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger~
188 Note, 2(46)| Cf. John Paul II, Apostolic Exhortation Familiaris consortio (
189 Note, 1(22)| edition was published and so appear only in the Italian edition.~
190 Note, 2 | other means”.25 The author applies this same standard of judgment
191 Note, 1 | than once the determinative approach of Moral de actitudes: “
192 Note, 1(10)| St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, I-II,
193 Note, 1 | language, and integrity of argumentation. ~The author states that
194 Note, 2 | conflicts of conscience arise, “the fundamental principle
195 Pre | succinct form, and should arrive at the Congregation for
196 Note, 1 | stress sufficiently the ascending vertical dimension of Christian
197 Pre | satisfaction Father Vidal’s assent and confirmed the agreed-upon
198 Pre | had been prepared with the assistance of an advisor chosen by
199 Note, 1 | avoid some of the errors associated with his chosen model, errors
200 Pre | decision, Father Vidal gave assurances through his Superior General
201 Note, 1 | Nazareth”,17 nevertheless, his attempt at a christological foundation
202 Note, 1 | magnanimity and understanding, attentive to the gradual and progressive
203 Note, 2 | must “adopt a provisional attitude”, formulated “from the perspective
204 Note, 1(8) | Letter Veritatis splendor (August 6, 1993), especially 36-
205 Note, 2 | according to which acts of autoeroticism are objectively intrinsically
206 Note, 1 | the paradigm of ‘theonomic autonomy’ reinterpreted through an ‘
207 Note, 2(47)| February 22, 1987), II, B, 5 AAS 80 (1988) 92–94.~
208 Note, 1 | contents.13 Only against the background of statements such as these
209 Pre | the Congregation, on the basis of all the phases of the
210 Note, 1 | theological virtues, prayer, the beatitudes, the resurrection, judgment,
211 | becoming
212 Note, 2 | objective elements of this behaviour and therefore “it is not
213 | below
214 Note, 2 | Ratzinger~Prefect~ ~+ Tarcisio Bertone, S.D.B.~Archbishop Emeritus
215 Note, 2 | does not enjoy an adequate biblical foundation28 and suffers
216 Note, 2 | reference to the objective and binding character of the moral norm
217 Note, 1(2) | Morale della persona e bioetica teologica (Assisi: Cittadella
218 Note, 1(2) | 1: Moral de la persona y bioética teológica (Madrid: Editorial
219 Pre | meeting, the Cardinal and Bishop Members of the Congregation
220 Note, 2 | what has traditionally been called “indirect abortion”, or
221 Pre | the Most Reverend Antonio Cañizares Llovera, Archbishop of Granada
222 Pre | Church in whose name he carries out his service of teaching
223 Note, 2 | which do not come under this category. His statements on eugenic
224 Note, 2(27)| sterilizationem in nosocomiis catholicis (March 13, 1974), AAS 68 (
225 Note, 2 | 2001, the Feast of the Chair of Peter, Apostle.~ ~+ Joseph
226 Note, 2 | the objective and binding character of the moral norm contained
227 Note, 1 | Moral de actitudes: “The characteristic and specific quality of
228 Note, 2 | likelihood of risk to the unborn child is removed as far as possible,
229 Note, 1 | fundamental option and concrete choices, which are incapable of
230 Note, 2(27)| Doctrine of the Faith, Response Circa sterilizationem in nosocomiis
231 Pre | and because of the wide circulation of these books and their
232 Pre | Vidal another opportunity to clarify his position on the points
233 Note, 2 | homosexuality possesses a certain coherence, but does not enjoy an adequate
234 Note, 2 | irreversibly homosexual, a coherent Christian commitment “does
235 Note, 2 | Magisterium, and trusts that his collaboration with the Doctrinal Commission
236 Note, 2 | procedures which do not come under this category. His
237 Note, 1 | rather as a partition which comes between man and God. Therefore,
238 Note, 1 | preferences”.21 In particular, his commentary on the Encyclical Veritatis
239 Note, 1 | while distinct, have a common source and end, and therefore
240 Pre | and precise answers, were communicated to Father Tobin at this
241 Note, 1(13)| would then have the task of completing with normative directives
242 Pre | Superior General that he would comply with the requests made by
243 Note, 1 | emancipation. He does not conceive of “‘ratio’ normativa”9
244 Note, 1 | detailed study of the principal concepts and themes of Christian
245 Note, 1 | teológica5 offers a more concise, but still sufficiently
246 Pre | the entire documentation, concluded the exceptional procedure.
247 Note, 2 | for success, and the human condition of the embryo is always
248 Note, 2 | the various methods,40 if conflicts of conscience arise, “the
249 Pre | and avoid their practical consequences in pastoral ministry.~ ~ ~
250 Note, 1 | possesses,11 and there is a consequent failure to recognize that
251 Note, 2(26)| Ma II/2, 575 = 652, which considers sterilization as an “adequate
252 Note, 2(46)| Apostolic Exhortation Familiaris consortio (November 22, 1981), 32:
253 Note, 2 | depenalization; some in practice constitute the legalization of abortion
254 Note, 1(22)| Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution Lumen Gentium, 25; Congregation
255 Note, 1 | expense of essential aspects constitutive of an integral presentation
256 Note, 2 | in the entire historical construct of Christian sexual ethics”.31
257 Note, 2 | Moral de Actitudes also contains ambiguous judgments on other
258 Note, 2 | the moral conscience would continue to be valid”.41 But even
259 Note, 1(13)| Scripture; all this is in contrast with the Encyclical Letter
260 Pre | a cordial and productive conversation regarding the doctrinal
261 Note, 2(34)| Cf. Rom 1: 24-27; 1 Cor 6:10; 1 Tm 1:10; Congregation
262 Pre | the Notification, and a cordial and productive conversation
263 Note, 2 | legislation, the author correctly asserts that abortion cannot
264 Note, 1 | errors which substantially correspond to those indicated in the
265 Note, 1(1) | number and page number; the corresponding text in the Italian translation
266 Note, 1(22)| Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution Lumen
267 Note, 2 | discernment of the married couple”.42 Among the various criteria
268 Note, 2 | for example, on married couples having recourse to artificial
269 Pre | Superior General in the course of a meeting at the Congregation
270 Note, 2 | therefore “it is not correct to create an ‘objective abstraction’
271 Note, 2 | couple”.42 Among the various criteria presented by the author
272 Note, 1 | teaching of the Church, critically distances himself from that
273 Note, 1 | such as redemption, the Cross, grace, the theological
274 Note, 2 | degree of subjective moral culpability in individual cases is not
275 Note, 1 | contemporary philosophical currents. However, this praiseworthy
276 Note, 2 | Tarcisio Bertone, S.D.B.~Archbishop Emeritus of Vercelli~
277 Note, 2 | It is inconsistent and dangerous to make an overall moral
278 Note, 1 | through a consideration of the data supplied by the human sciences
279 Pre | of an introduction, which dealt with the christological
280 Pre | subsequently be published. These decisions were confirmed by the Holy
281 Note, 1 | states that “Christ is the decisive norm of Christian ethics”
282 Note, 2 | fertilization cannot be declared immoral in principle”.49~
283 Note, 2 | ambiguities.30 It reflects the defects present “in the entire historical
284 Pre | themselves from these errors and deficiencies, and avoid their practical
285 Note, 1 | Veritatis splendor manifests a deficient notion of the competence
286 Note, 1 | theological methodology, proper definition of the moral object of an
287 Note, 2 | persons of the same sex.34 The degree of subjective moral culpability
288 Note, 1(3) | de Actitudes, II/2: Moral del amor y de la sexualidad (
289 Pre | Episcopal Conference, various Delegates named by this Dicastery,
290 Note, 1 | to each other simply to delineate their respective areas of
291 Pre | Superior General personally delivered to the Cardinal Prefect
292 Note, 1(3) | teologica, II-2a: Morale dell’amore e della sessualità (
293 Note, 1(13)| then has led to an actual denial that there exists, in divine
294 Note, 2 | be referring to laws that depenalize abortion.56 There are, however,
295 Note, 1 | but still sufficiently detailed study of the principal concepts
296 Note, 1 | expresses more than once the determinative approach of Moral de actitudes: “
297 Note, 2 | possible for the reader to determine what form of abortion depenalization
298 Note, 1(13)| revelation, a specific and determined moral context, universally
299 Note, 2 | in light of the further developments, confirmed his approval
300 Note, 1 | three volumes. The first is devoted to fundamental moral theology.1
301 Pre | Delegates named by this Dicastery, and Father Vidal, who was
302 Note, 2 | abortion.56 There are, however, different types of depenalization;
303 Note, 2 | intervention in some very difficult cases, it is not clear whether
304 Note, 2(27)| AAS 87 (1995), 466-467. On direct sterilization, see Paul
305 Note, 1(13)| completing with normative directives which are truly ‘objective,’
306 Pre | Respuesta a las “Preguntas dirigidas al Rev. P. Marciano Vidal,
307 Note, 2 | abortion is ambiguous.52 In his discussion of the possibility of medical
308 Pre | even when the author is disposed to correct his writings
309 Pre | in order that they may dissociate themselves from these errors
310 Note, 1 | faith and reason, while distinct, have a common source and
311 Note, 1 | theology.1 The second is divided into two parts, the first
312 Note, 1(5) | Navarra]: Editorial Verbo Divino, 1991), 649 pp. (henceforth
313 Note, 1(22)| Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution Lumen Gentium,
314 Note, 2 | insemination with the sperm of a donor,50 on heterologous in vitro
315 Note, 2(38)| splendidum nitentis (1054): DS 687-688.~
316 Note, 1 | incapable of positive resolution due to the inconsistencies in
317 | each
318 Note, 1(22)| Cf. Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, Dogmatic Constitution
319 Pre | They also decided that the editions of Moral de Actitudes (including
320 Note, 1 | nature of life and of moral education. It also seeks to moderate
321 | either
322 Note, 2 | conditions are objective elements of this behaviour and therefore “
323 Note, 1 | other, with a view towards emancipation. He does not conceive of “‘
324 Note, 2 | the human condition of the embryo is always respected, then “
325 Note, 2 | Bertone, S.D.B.~Archbishop Emeritus of Vercelli~Secretary~ ~ ~
326 Note, 1 | result of the moral paradigm employed, an insufficient role is
327 Note, 2 | Congregation also wishes to encourage moral theologians to pursue
328 | end
329 Note, 2 | coherence, but does not enjoy an adequate biblical foundation28
330 Note, 1(1) | PS, 1990), 8th edition (enlarged and completely revised),
331 Note, 1 | moral reasoning can be “enlightened by divine revelation and
332 Pre | two parts, the first on epistemological questions (the relationship
333 Pre | bioethics; social morality; eschatology – utopia). ~On June 4, 1998,
334 Note, 1 | undertaken at the expense of essential aspects constitutive of
335 Note, 1(5) | Diccionario de Ètica Teológica, (Estella [Navarra]: Editorial Verbo
336 Note, 1 | resurrection, judgment, and eternal life, are hardly mentioned
337 Note, 1 | quality of the Christian ethos is not to be found on the
338 Note, 1 | morality.4 The Diccionario de ética teológica5 offers a more
339 Note, 1 | for the Christian than the event of Jesus of Nazareth”,17
340 Note, 2 | asserts that the “gravity ex toto genere suo of masturbation”
341 Pre | in order to obtain more exact and precise answers, were
342 Pre | Congregation, by way of exception, to reformulate its questions
343 Pre | documentation, concluded the exceptional procedure. The Congregation
344 Note, 1 | responsibility in an exclusive and excluding manner, or to expand these
345 Note, 1 | of responsibility in an exclusive and excluding manner, or
346 Note, 1 | are hardly mentioned and exert almost no influence on his
347 Note, 1(13)| actual denial that there exists, in divine revelation, a
348 Note, 1 | excluding manner, or to expand these areas at the expense
349 Note, 1 | understanding and of lived experience of reality”,14 or in what
350 Pre | meeting aimed at obtaining explicit recognition of the errors
351 Note, 1 | by faith”.12 ~The author expresses more than once the determinative
352 Note, 1 | positions considered to be extreme through a consideration
353 Note, 1 | and there is a consequent failure to recognize that moral
354 Note, 2 | reasonable proportion between the failures and the well-founded hope
355 Note, 2(46)| II, Apostolic Exhortation Familiaris consortio (November 22,
356 Note, 2 | unborn child is removed as far as possible, and there is
357 Note, 2 | February 22, 2001, the Feast of the Chair of Peter, Apostle.~ ~+
358 Note, 1 | moral teaching, which are filtered through the author’s frequent “
359 Note, 1 | Consideration must be given, finally, to the tendency to make
360 Pre | the Congregation, which, finding it to be unsatisfactory,
361 Note, 2 | author and his willingness to follow the documents of the Magisterium,
362 Note, 1(1) | 1994), 958 pp.]. In the following notes, Moral de Actitudes
363 | former
364 Note, 1 | orientation”,15 a “new frame of reference” and a “dimension”.16
365 Note, 1 | the relationship between freedom and truth, conscience and
366 Note, 1 | filtered through the author’s frequent “options” and “preferences”.21
367 | further
368 Pre | for theological formation. Furthermore, they decided that Father
369 Pre | this decision, Father Vidal gave assurances through his Superior
370 Note, 2 | abortifacient. He maintains that, generally speaking, they cannot be
371 Note, 2 | that the “gravity ex toto genere suo of masturbation” has
372 Note, 1(13)| proposing an exhortation, a generic paraenesis, which the autonomous
373 Note, 1(22)| Dogmatic Constitution Lumen Gentium, 25; Congregation for the
374 Note, 2 | responsibility of the Magisterium to give positive and negative guidance
375 Note, 1 | foundation does not succeed at giving concrete ethical normativity
376 Note, 1 | often does not achieve its goal, because it is undertaken
377 Note, 2 | right;54 nevertheless, he goes on to state that “not all
378 Note, 1 | conflict of values or of goods in the study of various
379 Note, 1 | as redemption, the Cross, grace, the theological virtues,
380 Note, 1 | understanding, attentive to the gradual and progressive nature of
381 Pre | Cañizares Llovera, Archbishop of Granada and Member of the Congregation,
382 Pre | 1999, which also decided to grant Father Vidal an additional
383 Note, 2 | masturbation is ‘objectively grave matter’”.37 In this view,
384 Note, 1 | Christian moral life. And the great Christian themes, such as
385 Note, 2 | give positive and negative guidance on the use of the various
386 Note, 2 | presented by the author to guide this discernment,43 there
387 Note, 1 | judgment, and eternal life, are hardly mentioned and exert almost
388 Pre | widely-distributed works that may be harmful to the faith of the People
389 Note, 2 | example, on married couples having recourse to artificial insemination
390 Note, 1(5) | Divino, 1991), 649 pp. (henceforth cited as Det).~
391 | here
392 Note, 2 | morality of either becoming heterosexual or total abstinence”.33
393 | him
394 Note, 2 | the simple case’), we hold that it cannot be rejected...”.48
395 Note, 2 | the Church.27~The author holds that the doctrine of the
396 Note, 2 | person who is irreversibly homosexual, a coherent Christian commitment “
397 Note, 2(34)| 68 (1976), 84-85; Letter Homosexualitatis problema (October 1, 1987),
398 Note, 1 | to Jesus of Nazareth as horizon or new sphere of understanding
399 Note, 1 | laid out completely on a horizontal plane. Therefore, Moral
400 Note, 2 | fertilization limited to a husband and wife (‘the simple case’),
401 Note, 1(10)| Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, I-II, q. 100, a. 2, c.~
402 Note, 1(2) | Manuale di etica teologica, II-1a: Morale della persona e
403 Note, 1(3) | Manuale di etica teologica, II-2a: Morale dell’amore e della
404 Note, 2 | fertilization cannot be declared immoral in principle”.49~Moral de
405 Note, 2 | rightly affirms the overall immorality of abortion; however, his
406 Note, 1 | re-contextualizes the secular imperatives of a personalism of political
407 Note, 2 | fertilization and before implantation, are not abortifacient.
408 Note, 2 | particular gravity, when it is impossible to have recourse to other
409 Note, 1 | concrete choices, which are incapable of positive resolution due
410 Note, 2 | These positions are incompatible with Catholic doctrine,
411 Note, 1 | positive resolution due to the inconsistencies in the position taken by
412 Note, 2 | in every respect. “It is inconsistent and dangerous to make an
413 Pre | text of the Notification, incorporating the results of the meeting
414 | Indeed
415 Note, 2 | traditionally been called “indirect abortion”, or if he admits
416 Note, 1 | results from this is “an ethic influenced by faith”,20 but the influence
417 Note, 1 | morality.22 The author, while informing his readers about the teaching
418 Pre | have already been made. ~An initial study of certain works by
419 Note, 2 | from the perspective of inquiry and openness”.32 For the
420 Note, 2 | having recourse to artificial insemination with the sperm of a donor,50
421 Note, 1 | of ethics is acknowledged insofar as it “re-contextualizes
422 Pre | writings according to the instructions given. ~Informed of the
423 Note, 1 | aspects constitutive of an integral presentation of the Church’
424 Note, 1 | precision of language, and integrity of argumentation. ~The author
425 Pre | the works examined. It is intended for the good of the Christian
426 Note, 2 | problem, “given that the intention is to achieve a human good
427 Pre | person of the author, on his intentions, on the totality of his
428 Note, 2 | contraceptive methods which intervene after fertilization and
429 Note, 2 | the possibility of medical intervention in some very difficult cases,
430 | into
431 Pre | Redeemer. It was composed of an introduction, which dealt with the christological
432 Note, 2 | fundamental principle of the inviolability of the moral conscience
433 Pre | this new opportunity as an invitation to a deeper reflection,
434 Note, 2 | For the person who is irreversibly homosexual, a coherent Christian
435 Note, 2(38)| Church, 2352; >small 1Leo IX, Letter Ad splendidum nitentis (
436 Pre | Session of the Congregation on January 20, 1999, which also decided
437 Pre | situation, the Congregation judged it necessary to prepare
438 Note, 2 | also contains ambiguous judgments on other specific moral
439 Note, 2(27)| Encyclical Letter Humanae vitae (July 25, 1968), 14: AAS 60 (1968),
440 Note, 1 | influence is weak, because it is juxtaposed in fact to a secularized
441 Note, 1 | rather “on the level of the kind of world-view which accompanies”
442 Note, 1 | secularized rationality laid out completely on a horizontal
443 Note, 1 | of an act, precision of language, and integrity of argumentation. ~
444 Pre | text of the Respuesta a las “Preguntas dirigidas al
445 Note, 1 | and truth, conscience and law, fundamental option and
446 Note, 2 | abortion”, or if he admits the lawfulness of procedures which do not
447 Note, 2 | commitment “does not necessarily lead to the rigid morality of
448 Note, 1 | pre-moral level.23 This leads to a reductionistic treatment
449 Note, 1(13)| 1993), 1163: “This then has led to an actual denial that
450 Note, 2 | practice constitute the legalization of abortion and the others
451 Note, 2 | on to state that “not all liberalization of laws [on abortion] is
452 Note, 1 | reinterpreted through an ‘ethic of liberation’”.7 His objective is a personal
453 Note, 2 | cannot be considered morally licit means of birth control;24
454 Note, 2 | be rejected...”.48 If the likelihood of risk to the unborn child
455 Note, 1 | ratio’ normativa”9 as a link between man and God, which
456 Note, 1 | of understanding and of lived experience of reality”,14
457 Pre | Reverend Antonio Cañizares Llovera, Archbishop of Granada and
458 Note, 1 | God. Therefore, it is no longer possible to see “Divine
459 Note, 1 | second on the morality of love and sexuality.3 The third
460 Note, 1(22)| Council, Dogmatic Constitution Lumen Gentium, 25; Congregation
461 Note, 1 | dialogue is pursued with magnanimity and understanding, attentive
462 Note, 1 | in what sense it can be maintained that faith offers an “influence”,
463 | makes
464 Pre | General to Father Vidal, who manifested his acceptance by affixing
465 Pre | meeting. In addition, while manifesting the sincere hope that Father
466 Note, 1 | Encyclical Veritatis splendor manifests a deficient notion of the
467 Note, 2 | masturbation is ‘objectively grave matter’”.37 In this view, the judgment
468 Note, 1 | competence of the Magisterium in matters of morality.22 The author,
469 Note, 1 | these can one understand the meaning of “the reference to Jesus
470 Pre | This resolution is not meant as a judgment on the person
471 Note, 2 | discussion of the possibility of medical intervention in some very
472 Pre | Archbishop of Granada and Member of the Congregation, who
473 Pre | the Cardinal and Bishop Members of the Congregation in the
474 Note, 1 | associated with his chosen model, errors which substantially
475 Note, 1 | education. It also seeks to moderate positions considered to
476 Pre | substantial or concrete modification of the other doctrinal points
477 Pre | Vidal an additional three month period in which to make
478 | Moreover
479 Pre | that of the Church in whose name he carries out his service
480 Pre | Conference, various Delegates named by this Dicastery, and Father
481 | namely
482 Note, 1 | gradual and progressive nature of life and of moral education.
483 Note, 1(5) | Ètica Teológica, (Estella [Navarra]: Editorial Verbo Divino,
484 Note, 2 | Christian commitment “does not necessarily lead to the rigid morality
485 Note, 2 | Magisterium to give positive and negative guidance on the use of the
486 Note, 2(38)| IX, Letter Ad splendidum nitentis (1054): DS 687-688.~
487 | none
488 Note, 1 | not conceive of “‘ratio’ normativa”9 as a link between man
489 Note, 1(13)| task of completing with normative directives which are truly ‘
490 Note, 1 | giving concrete ethical normativity to the revelation of God
491 Note, 2(27)| Circa sterilizationem in nosocomiis catholicis (March 13, 1974),
492 Note | DOCTRINAL NOTE~
493 Note, 1 | splendor manifests a deficient notion of the competence of the
494 Pre | Faith, as well as the formal obligation to revise his writings according
495 Pre | its questions in order to obtain more exact and precise answers,
496 Pre | Vidal in a meeting aimed at obtaining explicit recognition of
497 Pre | the Advisor chosen for the occasion. After the formal presentation
498 Note, 1 | Although the author occasionally states that “Christ is the
499 Pre | necessary corrections. On some occasions, such a notification is
500 Note, 2(34)| Homosexualitatis problema (October 1, 1987), 3-8: AAS 79 (1987),
|