Dialogue

 1 Phaedo|          are demanded. One proof given is the same as that of the
 2 Phaedo|       them, and therefore either given before birth or at birth.
 3 Phaedo|         that it is not innate or given at birth, unless indeed
 4 Phaedo|      birth, unless indeed it was given and taken away at the same
 5 Phaedo|         same instant. But if not given to men in birth, it must
 6 Phaedo|         birth, it must have been given before birth—this is the
 7 Phaedo|          now an answer has to be given to the Theban Cadmus. Socrates
 8 Phaedo|        which is sometimes fairly given up and handed over to the
 9 Phaedo|       belong? Whatever answer is given by us to these questions,
10 Phaedo|     experience and had better be given up. The case of the animals
11 Phaedo|          6. Again, ideas must be given through something; and we
12 Phaedo|      become guardian angels,—had given place in the mysteries and
13 Phaedo|      well as in every other, has given distinctness to the hope
14 Phaedo|          fears an expression was given in the mysteries and Orphic
15 Phaedo|        ask; for no answer can be given to this question. And it
16 Phaedo|          of the way when you had given no intimation of your wish
17 Phaedo|         them such as ought to be given.~Then you are not of opinion,
18 Phaedo|           that these notions are given us at the very moment of
19 Phaedo|        be supplied; when that is given the demonstration will be
20 Phaedo|          Cebes, has been already given, said Socrates, if you put
21 Phaedo|          that no answer could be given to him, and therefore I
22 Phaedo|   satisfied with the explanation given, and not want any other
23 Phaedo|         No.~And this impress was given by the odd principle?~Yes.~
24 Phaedo|    opposites—as, in the instance given, three, although not opposed
25 Phaedo| imperishableness will have to be given.~No other proof is needed,
26 Phaedo|          after judgment has been given they pass into the world
27 Phaedo|         description which I have given of the soul and her mansions